Learn Bright

Direct Speech Punctuation

With our Direct Speech Punctuation lesson plan, students learn how to properly use commas and quotation marks when including quotations and direct speech in their writing.

Included with this lesson are some adjustments or additions that you can make if you’d like, found in the “Options for Lesson” section of the Classroom Procedure page. One of the optional additions to this lesson is to show a video of a conversation between two people and have students record the direct speech, using the correct punctuation.

Description

Additional information, what our direct speech punctuation lesson plan includes.

Lesson Objectives and Overview: Direct Speech Punctuation teaches students how to properly use commas and quotation marks when writing direct speech or quotations. This lesson is for students in 4th grade.

Classroom Procedure

Every lesson plan provides you with a classroom procedure page that outlines a step-by-step guide to follow. You do not have to follow the guide exactly. The guide helps you organize the lesson and details when to hand out worksheets. It also lists information in the green box that you might find useful. You will find the lesson objectives, state standards, and number of class sessions the lesson should take to complete in this area. In addition, it describes the supplies you will need as well as what and how you need to prepare beforehand. The only supplies needed for this lesson are the handouts, which you can copy ahead of time.

Options for Lesson

Included with this lesson is an “Options for Lesson” section that lists a number of suggestions for activities to add to the lesson or substitutions for the ones already in the lesson. One optional addition to this lesson is to show a video of a conversation between two people and have students record the direct speech, using the correct punctuation. You can also use a story that includes dialogue as an example of correctly written direct speech.

Teacher Notes

The teacher notes page includes a paragraph with additional guidelines and things to think about as you begin to plan your lesson. This page also includes lines that you can use to add your own notes as you’re preparing for this lesson.

DIRECT SPEECH PUNCTUATION LESSON PLAN CONTENT PAGES

Direct speech.

The Direct Speech Punctuation lesson plan includes three content pages. The lesson begins by reminding students that, when they speak to other people, the words they say are their own, and the sentences are created by their minds and belong to them. Likewise, when you read a comic book, the speech bubbles indicate the words of a specific character. These are both examples of direct speech.

Direct speech is different from indirect speech, which is when you relay the words of someone else, often not word-for-word. For example, if your mom says to tell your little brother it’s time for dinner, you could relay her words as indirect speech ( Mom told me to tell you we have to go eat ) or direct speech ( Mom said, “It is time for dinner” ). Direct speech means you are relaying the exact words said by another person. When you use indirect speech, there aren’t any special punctuation marks that you need to us.

However, we do have specific punctuation for direct speech, like commas and quotation marks. We use these when we show the direct speech of another person or of a character in a book. We also use them when quoting from a text, like a speech or an article.

Punctuating Direct Speech/Quotations

While students are familiar with commas and how to use them, they might not have a lot of practice using quotation marks in their writing. We use quotation marks for writing quotes. They look like pairs of upside-down commas. We place them before and after the quote. We also sometimes call them speech marks.

In the example sentence Tom said, “I have decided to stay home from school today.” we put a quotation mark before the first word that he said ( I ) and after the last word that he said ( today ) and the period. We also use a comma after the word said . It’s important to note that we put the second quotation mark after the period or other punctuation, not before.

The lesson includes several other examples that illustrate how to properly use commas and quotation marks for direct speech quotations. Students should review these examples to better understand where and how to use punctuation with quotations. One important rule they will learn is that you need a new paragraph for each speaker change. For example:

Oliver asked, “Where am I?”

Isla quietly answered, “You are at school. Wake up.”

It’s important to remember that we must punctuate the actual words being spoken with quotation marks, placed at the start and end of what’s being said. We can also use commas after the part of the sentence that tells you who is speaking. You can use words other than said  to indicate direct speech, like expressed, yelled, slowly said, silently answered , and more.

We also use quotation marks to mark quotations from a text. If you’re writing a report and want to include a sentence or fact from a book you read, you have to use quotation marks when using the exact wording from the book. The lesson includes an example of this.

Using proper punctuation for direct speech and quotations is very important, as it helps readers understand who is speaking and what they said.

DIRECT SPEECH PUNCTUATION LESSON PLAN WORKSHEETS

The Direct Speech Punctuation lesson plan includes three worksheets: an activity worksheet, a practice worksheet, and a homework assignment. You can refer to the guide on the classroom procedure page to determine when to hand out each worksheet.

RECORDING DIRECT SPEECH ACTIVITY WORKSHEET

Students will work in groups to complete the activity worksheet. To begin, two students in the group will choose a topic and discuss it for two minutes, taking turns speaking. Meanwhile, the other two members will write down as much of their conversation as possible using the space provided on the worksheet, listening carefully. They will then switch places and repeat. After both pairs have discussed a topic and recorded a conversation, they will take the information they’ve written down and correctly write the direct speech on the worksheet without using the word said .

CORRECTING SENTENCES PRACTICE WORKSHEET

The practice worksheet asks students to complete three exercises. The first asks them to correctly add commas and quotation marks to ten sentences where needed. Next, the second asks them to write a direct speech sentence for each of the given situations. The lesson provides an example for them to work from. Finally, the third asks them to read a paragraph and correctly add quotation marks where needed. They must also answer one final question about the paragraph.

DIRECT SPEECH PUNCTUATION HOMEWORK ASSIGNMENT

For the homework assignment, students will complete three short exercises. For the first, they will correctly rewrite a paragraph, replacing the word said with a better word. Next, they will read another paragraph and will correctly add quotation marks where needed. Finally, they will think about a conversation they recently had and will correctly write some of it out on the lines provided.

Worksheet Answer Keys

This lesson plan includes answer keys for the practice worksheet and the homework assignment. If you choose to administer the lesson pages to your students via PDF, you will need to save a new file that omits these pages. Otherwise, you can simply print out the applicable pages and keep these as reference for yourself when grading assignments.

Related products

This is the title page for the Careers: Archaeologist lesson plan. The main image is of an archaeologist brushing dirt off a bone. The orange Learn Bright logo is at the top of the page.

Careers: Archaeologist

This is the title page for the Vultures lesson plan. The main image is of four vultures. The orange Learn Bright logo is at the top of the page.

Careers: Computer Programmer

This is the title page for the Careers: Game Designer lesson plan. The main image is of a person playing a racing game on a game console. The orange Learn Bright logo is at the top of the page.

Careers: Game Designer

Make your life easier with our lesson plans, stay up-to-date with new lessons.

punctuating direct speech year 6 worksheet

  • Lesson Plans
  • For Teachers

© 2024 Learn Bright. All rights reserved. Terms and Conditions. Privacy Policy.

  • Sign Up for Free
  • Child Login
  • Number Sense
  • Measurement
  • Pre Algebra
  • Figurative Language
  • Reading Comprehension
  • Reading and Writing
  • Science Worksheets
  • Social Studies Worksheets
  • Math Worksheets
  • ELA Worksheets
  • Online Worksheets

Browse By Grade

  • Become a Member

Grammar

  • Kindergarten

Worksheets by Grade

  • Active and Passive Voice
  • Capitalization
  • Comparative and Superlative Adjectives
  • Conditionals
  • Conjunctions
  • Contractions
  • Determiners and Quantifiers
  • Diagramming Sentences
  • Direct and Indirect Objects
  • Direct and Indirect Speech
  • Double Negatives
  • Interjections
  • Parts of Speech
  • Phrasal Verbs
  • Prepositions
  • Punctuation
  • Question Words
  • Sentences for Beginners
  • Shift in Verb Tenses
  • Simple, Compound, and Complex Sentences
  • Subject and Object Complements
  • Subject and Predicate
  • Subject-Verb Agreement
  • Tag Questions
  • Transition Words
  • Types of Sentences

Vocabulary

  • Abbreviation
  • Alphabetical Order
  • Collocations
  • Commonly Confused Words
  • Compound Words
  • Connotations and Denotations
  • Crossword Puzzles
  • Positive and Negative Connotations
  • Shades of Meaning
  • Sorting and Categorizing
  • Word Search

Figurative Language

  • Alliteration
  • Onomatopoeia
  • Personification
  • Proverbs and Adages
  • Rhyming Words

Phonics

  • Beginning Sounds
  • Consonant Blends
  • Consonant Digraphs
  • Ending Sounds
  • Long and Short Vowels
  • Middle Sounds
  • R-Controlled Vowels
  • Silent Letters
  • Vowel Digraphs

Reading Comprehension

  • Kindergarten Reading Comprehension
  • Grade 1 Reading Comprehension
  • Grade 2 Reading Comprehension
  • Grade 3 Reading Comprehension
  • Grade 4 Reading Comprehension
  • Grade 5 Reading Comprehension
  • Grade 6 Reading Comprehension
  • Grade 7 Reading Comprehension
  • Grade 8 Reading Comprehension

Reading and Writing

  • Alphabet and Letters
  • Cause and Effect
  • Dictionary Skills
  • Editing and Proofreading
  • Facts and Opinions
  • Making Predictions
  • Word Recognition

Quotation Marks in Direct Speech Worksheets

  • Language Arts >
  • Grammar >
  • Punctuation >
  • Quotation Marks

Direct speech contains words that are actually uttered by the speaker and are enclosed in inverted commas known as quotation marks, quotes or speech marks. Working through these printable worksheets on quotation marks in direct speech, you need to place a comma after the introductory reporting clause. The end punctuation marks: ? and !, used with a question or an exclamation respectively, must also be placed before the closing quotation marks. Use these guidelines to rewrite the sentences in this set, and punctuate each of the given sentences with success.

These quotation marks in direct speech worksheets pdfs are ideal for grade 4 and grade 5 kids.

Quotation Marks in Direct Speech

Related Printable Worksheets

▶ Conjunctions and Commas

▶ Commas in a Series

Tutoringhour

What we offer, information.

  • Membership Benefits
  • How to Use Online Worksheets
  • How to Use Printable Worksheets
  • Printing Help
  • Testimonial
  • Privacy Policy
  • Refund Policy

Copyright © 2024 - Tutoringhour

Facebook

You must be a member to unlock this feature!

Sign up now for only $29.95/year — that's just 8 cents a day!

Printable Worksheets

  • 20,000+ Worksheets Across All Subjects
  • Access to Answer Key
  • Add Worksheets to "My Collections"
  • Create Custom Workbooks

Digitally Fillable Worksheets

  • 1100+ Math and ELA Worksheets
  • Preview and Assign Worksheets
  • Create Groups and Add Children
  • Track Progress

Resources you can trust

Direct speech

Direct speech

All reviews

Have you used this resource?

Resources you might like

Having trouble logging in? Some users have reported difficulties following a site update. If this includes you, please email [email protected] so we can get you up and running.

Making great literacy lessons easy. Why join Plazoom?

Year 6 SATs Practice - SPaG questions - Direct Speech

Resource Collection KS2 SATs Support

image of Year 6 SATs Practice - SPaG questions - Direct Speech

Subscribe today and receive…

  • Unlimited access to 1000s of resources
  • 80+ CPD guides and 60+ training videos
  • Access to THREE whole-school curriculums: - Real Writing - Real Comprehension - Real Grammar
  • The complete Word Whosh vocabulary building programme
  • Free subscription to Teach Reading & Writing magazine, and digital access to all back issues
  • Exclusive, member-only resource collections
  • New resources added every week

At the end of Key Stage 2, children in Year 6 complete the English grammar, punctuation and spelling test (GPS). Are your pupils ready?

This Year 6 SPaG Questions pack will support the practise of test style questions that pupils will face in paper 1 of the end of Key Stage 2 English Grammar, Punctuation and Spelling test.

These resources can be used alongside our Year 6 Revision Blaster worksheets to support revision in your classroom, in this case, of direct speech .

All our SPAG Questions and Revision Blaster resource packs focus on the content domains from the Key Stage 2 grammar, punctuation and spelling test framework (National Curriculum tests from 2016).

Content domains covered in this resource:

  • G5.7 inverted commas

This pack includes:

  • SPaG Questions PPT slides: Direct Speech
  • Let’s Practise! 1 and 2 PDF worksheets, (also shown on PPT slides 5 and 6)

What is direct speech?

Direct speech is when the exact words that someone says are written.

  • “We are going on an adventure,” said Travis.

How do we punctuate direct speech?

Inverted commas, or speech marks, are used when writing direct speech. The inverted commas go around what is said within a sentence. Other speech punctuation is also needed. Punctuation is needed at the end of the direct speech before the inverted comma, and a comma is used after the reporting clause if this comes before the direct speech.

  • Travis said, “We are going on an adventure.”

What is the reporting clause?

The reporting clause is the short clause that can come before or after the direct speech that states who was talking. It can also show how the speech was said.

  • “We are going on an adventure,” announced Travis.

This resource is part of the KS2 SATs Support collection. View more from this collection

  • Teacher notes

Trending Today

Ks2 comprehension – classic literature…, ks1 and ks2 writing templates for…, year 1 home learning pack (1), year 6 spelling revision – ks2…, look inside.

Click through to see what this resource has to offer

More from this collection

Ks2 sats spag revision blaster - commas, ks2 sats spag revision blaster - noun phrases, year 6 sats practice - spag questions - capital letters and full stops, year 6 sats practice - spag questions - modal verbs, synonyms and antonyms, year 6 sats practice - reading questions - non-fiction: ‘victory parade’, year 6 sats practice - reading questions - fiction: ‘a jaguar in the chicken coop’, year 6 sats practice - reading questions - fiction: ‘the wrath of vulcan’, ks2 sats spag revision blaster - apostrophes and hyphens, browse by year group, upgrade now.

Click 'Upgrade now' to activate your subscription. An invoice will appear on your accounts page and be sent by email. Once paid, the benefits of your full account will be unlocked within five days.

  • Kindergarten
  • Greater Than Less Than
  • Measurement
  • Multiplication
  • Place Value
  • Subtraction
  • Punctuation
  • 1st Grade Reading
  • 2nd Grade Reading
  • 3rd Grade Reading
  • Cursive Writing
  • Alphabet Coloring
  • Animals Coloring
  • Birthday Coloring
  • Boys Coloring
  • Buildings Coloring
  • Cartoons Coloring
  • Christmas Coloring
  • Country Flag Coloring
  • Country Map Coloring
  • Disney Coloring
  • Fantasy Coloring
  • Food Coloring
  • Girls Coloring
  • Holidays Coloring
  • Music Coloring
  • Nature Coloring
  • New Year Coloring
  • People Coloring
  • Religious Coloring
  • Sports Coloring
  • Toys Coloring
  • Transportation Coloring
  • US Sports Team Coloring
  • Valentine Day Coloring

Direct Speech Year 6

Displaying top 8 worksheets found for - Direct Speech Year 6 .

Some of the worksheets for this concept are Direct speech, Direct and indirect speech, Punctuating direct speech, Grade 6 vocabulary work, Direct to indirect speech, Direct and indirect speech rules, Grammar and punctuation work, Direct speech work for grade 4.

Found worksheet you are looking for? To download/print, click on pop-out icon or print icon to worksheet to print or download. Worksheet will open in a new window. You can & download or print using the browser document reader options.

1. Direct Speech

2. direct and indirect speech, 3. punctuating direct speech, 4. grade 6 vocabulary worksheets, 5. direct to indirect speech, 6. direct and indirect speech rules, 7. grammar and punctuation worksheets, 8. direct speech worksheet for grade 4.

Notification Bell

Direct Speech Punctuation

Loading ad...

Profile picture for user Anita_Kaya

Speech Marks

  • Google Classroom
  • Microsoft Teams
  • Download PDF

Direct Speech Punctuation

  • International
  • Schools directory
  • Resources Jobs Schools directory News Search

Direct Speech: Punctuating.

Direct Speech: Punctuating.

Subject: English

Age range: 11-14

Resource type: Worksheet/Activity

TesEnglish

Last updated

16 August 2021

  • Share through email
  • Share through twitter
  • Share through linkedin
  • Share through facebook
  • Share through pinterest

pdf, 99.1 KB

Creative Commons "Sharealike"

Your rating is required to reflect your happiness.

It's good to leave some feedback.

Something went wrong, please try again later.

Karenleslie07

Empty reply does not make any sense for the end user

pjpnightingale

really helpful thanks

Report this resource to let us know if it violates our terms and conditions. Our customer service team will review your report and will be in touch.

Not quite what you were looking for? Search by keyword to find the right resource:

IMAGES

  1. Quotation Marks in Direct Speech Worksheets

    punctuating direct speech year 6 worksheet

  2. KS2 Punctuating Direct Speech SPaG Teaching Pack And Worksheets

    punctuating direct speech year 6 worksheet

  3. Direct Speech Punctuation

    punctuating direct speech year 6 worksheet

  4. Direct Speech / Inverted Commas Worksheets by Inspire and Educate

    punctuating direct speech year 6 worksheet

  5. Direct Speech Punctuation

    punctuating direct speech year 6 worksheet

  6. 26 Fun Punctuation Resources and Activities

    punctuating direct speech year 6 worksheet

VIDEO

  1. Narration

  2. Top Tips for Revising Spelling, Grammar & Punctuation with Flashcards

  3. Punctuating Questions Quiz

  4. Year 6 Academy Stars Workbook Answer Page 55

  5. Direct and indirect speech Class-5 Lesson-15 Everyday English grammar and Composition #english#video

  6. English Dictation (16) ll Dictation In English For Class 6, 7 & 8

COMMENTS

  1. PDF Direct Speech: Missing Punctuation

    6. "Oh, yes, please!" said Cole, leaning forward eagerly. "I've always wanted to do magic." Direct Speech: Missing Punctuation Answers Challenge: correctly punctuate this passage of text from the story. Piog raised an eyebrow. "If you think this is delicious, food must be disgusting in your world."

  2. Direct Speech Punctuation Worksheets

    Inside, you will find 3 differentiated direct speech punctuation worksheets that you can use to tailor your activities to your children's understanding and abilities. We have also included a page of lined paper that your students can use to complete their direct speech punctuation activities, as well as answer sheets for each worksheet.

  3. Direct Speech Worksheets (KS2)

    Direct Speech Worksheets (KS2) Three differentiated resources that focus on direct speech and being able to punctuate it accurately. These sheets are made with mastery in mind, taking elements of the mastery approach to Maths and applying these to English. Each sheet tells children what they need to do as well as having answers available.

  4. PDF Punctuating direct speech

    Punctuating direct speech. Direct speech means the bits of a sentence that are actually being spoken; like the words you would find in a speech bubble. Punctuating direct speech can seem complicated. Here is a step‐by‐step guide to getting it right. Speech marks always need to go at the start and end of what is being said: "Are you coming ...

  5. Teaching Pack: Using & Punctuating Speech KS2 (teacher made)

    Included is an inverted commas punctuation poster, speech sentence order cards and editable speech bubble cards. Ideal for Years 3-6 students, it features everything you need to get your KS2 students punctuating direct and indirect speech correctly. This punctuating speech KS2 teaching pack is teacher-made to ensure your students receive high ...

  6. How to Punctuate Direct Speech Worksheet

    In this worksheet, students practise correctly adding commas, quotation marks, capital letters, full stops and other forms of punctuation to the sentences provided. Sometimes the quoted speech occurs at the beginning of the sentence, at other times it is found in the middle or at the end. Lay the groundwork that will enable your students to ...

  7. Direct Speech Punctuation Worksheets Differentiated

    pdf, 2.66 MB. Four worksheets aimed at learning how to accurately punctuate direct speech. The worksheets are differentiated to cover a range of difficulty levels. The speech punctuation used includes inverted commas (speech marks), capital letters, commas and end of sentence punctuation (full stops, exclamation marks or question marks).

  8. Direct Speech Punctuation Worksheets

    Targeted SPaG practice worksheets to reinforce Year 6 students' ability to correctly punctuate direct speech using speech marks, full stops, commas, colons, question & exclamation marks. This pack contains 65 unrepeated practice questions (with answers) that are spread across 6 self-contained exercises, including: Ticking boxes.

  9. Direct Speech Punctuation, Free PDF Download

    Direct Speech. The Direct Speech Punctuation lesson plan includes three content pages. The lesson begins by reminding students that, when they speak to other people, the words they say are their own, and the sentences are created by their minds and belong to them. Likewise, when you read a comic book, the speech bubbles indicate the words of a ...

  10. Speech Marks

    Our direct speech punctuation worksheets are teacher-made to ensure that your students have easy access to high-quality resources while saving you valuable planning time! This Speech Marks Worksheet contains pages from a Twinkl Originals story, ' Under the Lights '. Simply download and print these direct speech punctuation worksheets by ...

  11. Quotation Marks in Direct Speech Worksheets

    Quotation Marks in Direct Speech Worksheets. Direct speech contains words that are actually uttered by the speaker and are enclosed in inverted commas known as quotation marks, quotes or speech marks. Working through these printable worksheets on quotation marks in direct speech, you need to place a comma after the introductory reporting clause.

  12. Use and Punctuating Speech KS2 Teaching Ideas Pack

    This is a fantastic resource and lesson planning ideas pack that can teach key skills in writing, punctuating and recognising direct speech at a KS2 level. This pack brings you 12 beautifully illustrated, teacher-made resources, including: Direct speech KS2 speech bubbles - brilliant for display or interactive learning to give your KS2 examples ...

  13. PDF Direct Speech

    Marks.PDF. Direct Speech - Speech. Speech marks inverted (or ) show commas when someone You will see them " speech written " or ' sp ' ech . in books. Task One. Copy these sentences into your correct Rememb places. r: The speech marks said. Copy all the other punctuation. 1. Hello, said the man. 2.

  14. Cole's Kingdom Direct Speech Punctuation KS2 Differentiated Worksheet

    This useful set of diferentiated worksheets is perfect for KS2 punctuation practice. Using extracts from the fiction text 'Cole's Kingdom' from Twinkl Originals, children are invited to add speech marks, commas and full stops to lines of dialogue from the story. Perfect as a KS2 writing intervention activity or for whole-class punctuation practice, or in preparation for Y6 SATs.

  15. Direct speech practice

    KS3. Category. Punctuation: Direct speech. Resource type. Worksheet. This is a really clear punctuation worksheet to consolidate direct speech skills with students. It's a step-by-step guide to writing full dialogue with three different exercises. 51.64 KB. Free download.

  16. Speech Marks

    Our direct speech punctuation worksheets are teacher-made to ensure that your students have easy access to high-quality resources while saving you valuable planning time! This Speech Marks Worksheet contains pages from a Twinkl Originals story, ' Under the Lights '. Simply download and print these direct speech punctuation worksheets by ...

  17. 393 Top "Speech Punctuation Year 6" Teaching Resources curated ...

    Level 3 Writing Punctuation Lesson 5: Speech Marks - Dialogue 1 review. Explore more than 393 "Speech Punctuation Year 6" resources for teachers, parents and pupils as well as related resources on "Speech Punctuation". Instant access to inspirational lesson plans, schemes of work, assessment, interactive activities, resource packs, PowerPoints ...

  18. KS2 KS3 literacy punctuation speech marks direct and indirect speech

    Three short literacy worksheets about identifying and correctly punctuating direct and indirect speech, and converting between them. Ideal for year 5 (who are confident readers), year 6, and maybe year 7 and year 8. Works well as a starter, main SPAG activity, homework, home learning or cover work.

  19. Year 6 SATs Practice

    This Year 6 SPaG Questions pack will support the practise of test style questions that pupils will face in paper 1 of the end of Key Stage 2 English Grammar, Punctuation and Spelling test. These resources can be used alongside our Year 6 Revision Blaster worksheets to support revision in your classroom, in this case, of direct speech.

  20. Direct Speech Year 6 Worksheets

    Displaying top 8 worksheets found for - Direct Speech Year 6. Some of the worksheets for this concept are Direct speech, Direct and indirect speech, Punctuating direct speech, Grade 6 vocabulary work, Direct to indirect speech, Direct and indirect speech rules, Grammar and punctuation work, Direct speech work for grade 4.

  21. Direct Speech Punctuation worksheet

    Direct Speech Punctuation. Loading ad... Anita_Kaya Member for 3 years 7 months Age: 8-15. Level: Grade 6. Language: English (en) ID: 1565970. 25/10/2021 ... Interactive Worksheets For Students & Teachers of all Languages and Subjects. Worksheets. Worksheets; Make Interactive Worksheets; Browse Worksheets; Wookbooks. Workbooks; Learn.

  22. SPaG Presentation: Punctuating Direct Speech ( Inverted Commas)

    SPaG Presentation: Punctuating Direct Speech ( Inverted Commas) Subject: English. Age range: 7-11. Resource type: Other. File previews. pptx, 774.88 KB. PPT covers the distinction between reported and direct speech plus how to punctuate direct speech correctly. Contains examples of each, opportunities for pupil participation and a quiz at the ...

  23. Direct Speech: Punctuating.

    A range of tasks and activities punctuating direct speech. Revision worksheet. Improve students' punctuation. Creative Commons "Sharealike" Reviews. 4.7 Something went wrong, please try again later. Karenleslie07. 4 years ago. report. 5. Empty reply does not make any sense for the end user ...