essay books are better than movies

Find a blog post

Books vs. movies: the age-old debate.

The Mountain Between Us , It , Murder on the Orient Express , Wonder , My Cousin Rachel . These films released in 2017 have one thing in common, and you may have guessed it already: They were all books that were later adapted into movies.

Similar to its affinity for sequels and remakes , it seems to me like Hollywood is increasingly looking to books for inspiration for the next blockbuster hits. From a business standpoint, it makes total sense because producers can draw on the popularity of a certain book and use that to their advantage when it comes to marketing the film’s release.

As an avid reader, I am always excited at the news that a book is being adapted as a feature film. My mind is occupied by thoughts of who the actors/actresses are going to be (and if I approve), if the film will stay true to the book, and most importantly, if the movie will be just as good as the book. The thought of finally being able to visualize what has only previously been limited to my imagination is always an exciting prospect.

However, I am usually underwhelmed after watching a certain film based on a book, and if you asked me a year ago which one I would prefer: the movie or the book, I would have immediately chosen the book.

Hands down. No doubt. However, within the past year, I have come to appreciate movie adaptations of books more because I have realized that comparing books to their counterpart movies isn’t fair; at the end of the day, the two mediums of storytelling have different advantages and different qualifications for what makes them good. Like Stephen King once said, comparing one to the other is like comparing apples to oranges. They are both great sources of entertainment, but they aren’t comparable. For those still reluctant to accept this theory, I’ll be delving more into this age-old question: “What’s better: books or movies?” I’ll make a case for each argument and let you make the final call.

The popular belief is that books are often a hundred times better than their movie counterparts; if you need any further proof, just take a look at the following Washington Post visual.

Books are great because they allow the reader to be a part of the story; we are the observers that have insight into the character’s thoughts and feelings, and all the nuances that create three-dimensional characters. With books, there’s just more. More detail, more focus on character development, and more depth to the meaning of the artwork. It’s also the more time-consuming form of the two, and after finishing a novel, after a couple of hours of being immersed into a different world and mind space, it seems like you have suddenly been thrust back into reality.

On the other hand, the great thing about movies is their ability to show, and the overall experience of watching one. While reading a book, I often have a movie reel playing in my head. I can map out the setting, I can see the characters’ expressions, and I can empathize with their emotions.

However, watching the same story unfold on the big screen is a different experience. While reading spurs your imagination, a movie helps you visualize all the elements of the books that were previously confined to your imagination. It immerses you into the story in a different way than a book.

For example, instead of reading about the magical world of Harry Potter, while watching the movie, I can actually see what J.K. Rowling means by “He was almost twice as tall as a normal man and at least five times as wide. He looked simply too big to be allowed, and so wild – long tangles of bushy black hair and beard hid most of his face, he had hands the size of dustbin lids and his feet in their leather boots were like baby dolphins.” To put it simply, movies make it easier for us to just lean back and enjoy the show.

An added benefit of movies is the music and visual designs that enhance the experience of watching a film. Imagine, for example, that you are watching an emotional scene. It’s the climax of the story, and in the background plays a gentle orchestra, that eventually swells into a big crescendo as the story reaches its resolution. In that moment, you feel exactly what the characters feel, and your heart races along with the melody of the music. So although (in some cases) the audience might not have a play by play of the characters’ thoughts and emotions, movies have another way of conveying the emotion and tone of a certain scene.

If you feel like further exploring this age-old debate personally, come down to Media Services to check out movies even the worst critic would have to admit are just as good as the books. Don’t know where to start? Try Pride and Prejudice, Psycho, Jaws, The Godfather, etc.

Until next time! RE

Robiati Endashaw is a sophomore studying public policy analysis in KSB with a minor in Economics. In her spare time, she enjoys reading non-fiction and watching crime documentaries.

Oh gee thanks so much . I also feel quite the same way too when it comes to books as in they are so much enjoyable because they allow us as the reader to explore the depths of my imagination and every thing happening Is felt dearly. 😊

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed .

Social media

• Instagram for Herman B Wells Library
• Facebook for IU Libraries

Additional resources

Featured databases.

• Resource available to authorized IU Bloomington users (on or off campus) OneSearch@IU
• Resource available to authorized IU Bloomington users (on or off campus) Academic Search (EBSCO)
• Resource available to authorized IU Bloomington users (on or off campus) ERIC (EBSCO)
• Resource available to authorized IU Bloomington users (on or off campus) Nexis Uni
• Resource available without restriction HathiTrust Digital Library
• Databases A-Z
• Resource available to authorized IU Bloomington users (on or off campus) Google Scholar
• Resource available to authorized IU Bloomington users (on or off campus) JSTOR
• Resource available to authorized IU Bloomington users (on or off campus) Web of Science
• Resource available to authorized IU Bloomington users (on or off campus) Scopus
• Resource available to authorized IU Bloomington users (on or off campus) WorldCat

IU Libraries

• Diversity Resources
• About IU Libraries
• Alumni & Friends
• Departments & Staff
• Jobs & Libraries HR
• IU Libraries Blog
• Intranet (Staff)
• Login (Blogs admin)

To Watch or to Read: The Great Debate of Books vs. Movies

The debate between books vs. movies has been raging for decades. Some people prefer the immersive experience of reading a good book, while others enjoy the visual and auditory spectacle of a blockbuster movie. While both mediums have their own unique advantages and disadvantages, there is no denying that they both offer a powerful and engaging way to tell a story.

In this article, we will explore the pros and cons of both books and movies and delve into the reasons why some people prefer one medium over the other. We will also examine the impact that film adaptations have had on the literary world, and how books and movies have influenced and inspired each other over the years.

Through this exploration, we hope to provide a better understanding of the book vs. movie debate and help readers decide which medium they prefer. Whether you’re a die-hard bookworm or a film buff, there’s no denying that both books and movies have a place in our cultural landscape. So sit back, relax, and join us as we explore the great debate of book vs. movie.

Book Vs Movie: Compare And Contrast

Books vs. movies: The age-old debate. Here’s a chart summarizing the key differences between books and movies:

These are just a few of the many differences between books and movies, and there is no right or wrong choice when it comes to deciding which medium you prefer. It ultimately comes down to personal preference and what you enjoy most in a story.

The Advantages of Reading a Book Over Watching a Movie

Books and movies are two very different forms of media. While movies can be visually stunning and entertaining, books offer a deeper, more immersive experience that simply can’t be replicated on the big screen. In this section, we’ll explore some of the key advantages of reading a book over watching a movie and find out the reasons why good books are better than movies.

Reading a book offers a more immersive experience than a movie, as it allows readers to delve deeper into the story and form a stronger connection to the characters. With more extensive descriptions of people, places, and events, readers can visualize the story in their own way and bring their own experiences and perspectives to the reading experience. This personal connection is not possible with a movie, which visualizes the story for the viewer.

Reading also has cognitive benefits, improving memory, focus, and concentration, as readers actively process and make connections between story elements. Additionally, reading expands vocabulary and language skills, exposing readers to a wider range of words and sentence structures.

While movies have their own unique advantages, such as a cinematic experience and visual and auditory stimulation, reading a book offers a deeper, more engaging experience that cannot be matched by any other medium. Overall, the benefits of reading make it an essential and highly rewarding activity.

The Advantages of Watching a Movie Over Reading a Book

While there are numerous advantages to reading a book, there are also many reasons why watching a movie can be a more enjoyable and fulfilling experience. In this section, we’ll explore some of the key advantages of watching a movie over reading a book and find out the reasons why movies are better than books.

Movies have a distinct advantage over books due to their visual medium, which can create stunning visuals, deliver visceral impacts, and transport viewers to different worlds. Movies are also more convenient than books, as they require less time and effort to enjoy. Additionally, movies are accessible to a broader audience, including young children and those with limited literacy skills. 

Finally, movies offer a shared experience that can bond friends and family and create lasting memories. While books offer a deeper, more immersive experience and can improve cognitive functioning and language skills, movies should not be overlooked. Movies are an essential and valuable part of our culture, and their unique advantages should be appreciated.

The Importance of Originality: The Book vs. Movie Debate

The importance of originality is a crucial factor in the debate of book vs. movie. Books and movies require originality to stand out in their respective mediums. 

In books, originality is crucial to the success of the story, as readers are looking for something new and fresh. Authors who can deliver original and compelling stories are more likely to attract a loyal following of readers. 

On the other hand, movies need to offer something unique and different from what has come before to succeed in a crowded marketplace. Audiences want to be entertained and challenged, to see something they haven’t seen before. The challenge lies in adapting a book for the screen, as movies need to capture the essence of the original story while also offering something new and original to viewers. A successful movie adaptation captures the spirit of the original story while also offering something fresh and unique to the audience. 

Overall, originality is crucial for both books and movies to be successful and memorable.

The Impact of Film Adaptations on Book Sales

Film adaptations of books have become common in the entertainment industry, and their impact on book sales is significant. A successful movie adaptation can result in a surge of book sales and increased attention for the author. However, a poorly received adaptation can damage the reputation of the source material and turn potential readers away. 

The impact of film adaptations on book sales can also vary depending on the genre of the book , with young adult novels having a particularly strong impact. A successful adaptation can also lead to increased interest in the author and their other works. 

Nonetheless, the relationship between books and movies is complex, and a delicate balance must be struck between staying true to the source material and offering something new and original. 

Despite the challenges, it is clear that the relationship between books and movies is important, with each medium having the potential to influence and enhance the other.

Comparing the Popularity of Books and Movies: A Statistical Analysis

This section explores the popularity of books and movies by analyzing sales figures and audience engagement. 

According to the Association of American Publishers, book sales in the US reached $25.8 billion in 2020, while global box office revenue for movies was $42.2 billion in 2019. However, these figures are not necessarily indicative of overall popularity, as the success of a book or movie can depend on various factors such as genre and marketing. 

In terms of audience engagement, a survey by the Pew Research Center found that 65% of American adults reported reading a book in print or digital format in 2019, while data from the Motion Picture Association shows that the average US moviegoer attended about 5 movies in theaters in 2019 . 

Nonetheless, it is important to note that reading books and watching movies are not mutually exclusive activities, and personal preference and taste play a significant role in determining the popularity of these two forms of entertainment. 

Ultimately, both books and movies have the potential to provide enjoyable and meaningful experiences for viewers and readers alike.

Why Some Movies Fail to Capture the Essence of the Book

Movie adaptations of books often face challenges in capturing the essence of the original work. The biggest challenge is condensing the story into a shorter running time, which can result in a movie that feels rushed or incomplete, with important plot points or character development left out. 

Another challenge is finding the right tone and style, as books can be written in a variety of styles, from lyrical and poetic to straightforward and simple. Filmmakers may make changes to the story or characters that alter the tone or style of the original work, resulting in a movie that feels different from the book. Inner thoughts and emotions, which are extensively described in books, can be difficult to convey visually, leading to clunky or awkward voiceovers or other techniques. 

Lastly, some movies fail to capture the essence of the book simply because they are not faithful to the original work, as filmmakers may make changes that are not in line with the author’s vision.

Overall, adapting a book to a movie is a challenging task that requires balancing various elements such as condensing the story, finding the right tone, conveying inner experiences, and staying faithful to the original work. However, when done well, a movie adaptation can provide a fresh perspective on a beloved story and introduce new audiences to the world of the book.

How Movies Can Enhance or Detract from the Reading Experience

Movies can impact the experience of reading books in both positive and negative ways. While a well-made movie adaptation can bring a story to life in a new way and provide new insights into the characters and settings, it can also limit your imagination and leave out important details or changes that affect the overall meaning of the story

A movie adaptation can enhance the reading experience by providing a visual representation of the story and bringing new nuances to the characters and events. On the other hand, movies can detract from the reading experience by limiting the reader’s imagination and leaving out important details or changing aspects of the story that affect its overall meaning. When a movie adaptation leaves out a key subplot or character, the story may feel incomplete, and if it changes the ending of the story, it can alter the entire meaning of the book. 

Ultimately, the decision to read a book or watch a movie adaptation is a personal one and depends on the individual’s preferences and the specific book and movie in question.

Does Reading the Book First Ruin the Movie Experience?

The debate over whether reading the book before watching the movie adaptation ruins the movie experience has been ongoing. Some people believe that knowing the story beforehand takes away the suspense and surprises that make movies enjoyable, while others argue that reading the book first enhances the movie experience. 

Those against reading the book first argue that it takes away from the suspense and surprise of the movie and leads to constant comparison with the book. However, reading the book first can also provide a deeper understanding of the story and characters, making the story more meaningful and impactful. It can also help fill in gaps that are often left out in the movie adaptation. Movies have to condense the story, leaving out important details or subplots, which can leave viewers feeling confused or unsatisfied. 

Ultimately, whether reading the book first ruins the movie experience is a matter of personal preference. It’s up to the individual to decide whether they want to read the book first or wait to see the movie without any prior knowledge of the story.

The Role of Directors and Screenwriters in Adapting Books for Film

Adapting a book into a film is a challenging task that requires a skilled director and screenwriter to bring the story to life on the big screen. They must carefully decide which elements of the book should be included in the movie, considering the pacing, structure, characters, and motivations, to ensure that the movie stays true to the spirit of the book while also being entertaining for moviegoers. Without understanding the psychology of movie watchers, a movie hardly gets success at the box office. The tone and mood of the book must also be captured in the movie adaptation, which can be particularly challenging when adapting books known for their unique style or voice.

Practical constraints of the movie medium must also be considered, such as deciding which scenes and characters can realistically be portrayed on screen and which elements of the story may need to be altered or omitted to fit within the constraints of the movie format.

The success of a movie adaptation depends on the skill and creativity of the director and screenwriter, who must work together to craft a cinematic experience that stays true to the book while also being engaging for moviegoers. When done well, a movie adaptation can bring a beloved book to life in a new and exciting way, creating a powerful and memorable cinematic experience.

The Future of Books and Movies: Will One Outlast the Other?

The future of books and movies is uncertain, and it is difficult to predict which medium will outlast the other. 

Books have been around for centuries and provide an immersive experience, allowing readers to engage with the story and characters. They have a wide range of genres and subject matter, making them accessible to a broad audience. On the other hand, movies offer a unique cinematic experience that cannot be replicated by any other medium. They visually immerse viewers in the story and characters and can reach a wider audience through mass distribution in theaters and online streaming platforms.

However, concerns remain about the future of both mediums. The rise of e-books and audiobooks and the decline of traditional print books are concerns for the book industry, while the decline of movie theaters and the rise of streaming services are affecting the movie industry. 

Despite these concerns, both books and movies have shown resilience over time. While the formats may change, the desire for stories and entertainment will always be present. It is likely that both mediums will coexist in the future, with each offering its unique benefits to audiences.

The debate between books and movies will continue as both have their unique advantages and disadvantages, and the choice depends on personal preference. While books provide an immersive experience and movies offer a unique cinematic experience, the impact of movie adaptations on book sales and the role of directors and screenwriters in the adaptation process is crucial. Both books and movies have influenced and inspired each other, but some movies fail to capture the essence of the book. 

Ultimately, both mediums have a place in our cultural landscape, and it’s important to celebrate and appreciate their unique benefits while enjoying the stories and characters they bring to life.

So, Keep Watching and Be Bookish !

Dennis K. Hawkins is a writer, blogger, book critic and bookish person. He has written several books and regularly write blogs. As a bookish, he reads a lot and regularly share his opinion regarding books. Besides, he has a huge collection of unique accessories related to book. So, he is an expert and also a real user of the book accessories that he chooses to write on.

Similar Posts

Book Versus Novel: Understanding the Important Differences and Similarities

Book versus novel is a vital topic that everyone should know. Books and novels are two terms that are often used interchangeably, but they have distinct differences. A book can refer to any written material that is bound together, while a novel is a specific type of book that is typically fictional and focuses on…

Kingstone Bible vs Action Bible: Which is the Best?

Kingstone Bible vs Action Bible has become a dilemma now-a-days for many people. My son and daughter just started to go to school. As this is the root time of their education, I see no other way of teaching them the values and perceptions of norms and culture of this society. I started by giving…

Ink and Pixels: Navigating the Battle of Physical Books Vs eBooks

In an era dominated by digital technology, the age-old debate of Physical Books vs eBooks remains a significant topic of discussion among avid readers. The choice between these two formats involves a careful consideration of the unique advantages and drawbacks they each bring to the table. While technology has revolutionized the way we access and…

Book Page Holder: A Great Tool for Readers

If you’re an avid reader, then you know the great use of book page holder because it reminds you how frustrating it is to lose your place in a book. Whether your bookmark falls out or you just can’t seem to keep your finger on the page, it’s annoying to have to constantly flip back…

Pen Vs Keyboard: Which is Better? Writing By Hand Vs Typing

In today’s fast-paced digital world, the age-old debate of pen vs keyboard, in other words, writing by hand vs typing, continues to captivate the minds of students, professionals, and creatives alike. The rise of technology has made typing the norm, with keyboards replacing pens as the primary tool for jotting down notes, composing essays, and…

How to Read Books at Night Without Light: Important Tips for Bookish!

Do you love reading books but find it difficult to read at night without light? If so, then this blog post is for you! Here are some tips on how to read books at night without light! Bookish people love to read books at night while having no other sound. It helps concentrate on reading,…

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment.

• Non-Fiction
• Author’s Corner
• Reader’s Corner
• Writing Guide
• Book Marketing Services
• Write for us

Why Books Are Better Than Movies

Companions, Not Replacements

Remember that feeling? You’ve been devouring this incredible book for weeks, getting utterly lost in its world. The characters have become like friends; their struggles and triumphs giving you all the feels. Their adventures have been unfolding so vividly in your mind’s eye thanks to the author’s brilliant descriptions. But now the final page has turned, and you’re not ready to let them go just yet.

So, of course, you rush out to see the big, shiny new film adaptation the moment it hits theaters. You’re practically vibrating with excitement to see these beloved characters brought to life before your eyes. You eagerly grab your popcorn…and then, crushing disappointment. What gives? Why did the movie feel so pale and shallow compared to the book’s rich experience?

I’ve lived that head-scratching letdown more times than I care to admit, most recently with the new Netflix series adapting Liu Cixin’s mind-twisting sci-fi epic The Three-Body Problem . Don’t get me wrong, I’m always stoked to see stories I love get the Hollywood treatment – there’s a special thrill in watching a familiar world literally move and breathe in live-action.

But if I’m being honest, movies and shows rarely manage to capture the depth and imaginative richness of a truly great book. While adaptations immerse us through dazzling visuals and soundscapes, the written word engages our creativity to an infinitely more profound degree. Films show us other worlds, but books let us co-create them.

Directing From the Armchair

Think about it – whenever you dive into a new novel, you’re handed the ultimate director’s chair. Sure, the author provides the descriptive blueprint, but crafting the actual setting, character appearances, and emotional vibes? That all falls to your one-of-a-kind imagination.

Was Professor McGonagall’s stern bun even tighter in your Harry Potter brainscape? Did the gnarly branches of the Whomping Willow seem even more menacing and violently thrashing compared to the movies? Maybe the landscapes of Middle-Earth felt lusher and more primordial in your Lord of the Rings visions.

That’s the special magic of getting deliciously lost in a good book. You’re awash in an intimately imaginative process that not even the most cutting-edge CGI spectacle can replicate. As cinematic as the latest franchise blockbuster looks, the visuals were still created by someone else’s artistic team and budget constraints. But when you’re reading, the only limit is your own artistic creativity.

Don’t get me wrong, I’ll always be first in line for those big-budget page-to-screen epics. There’s an undeniable thrill in watching the wizarding world or Pandora’s lush alien landscapes brought to vivid life. But part of me also longs for my own mind’s distinctive interpretation, before the movies colored my imagination.

The Sky’s The Limit

Speaking of budgets, here’s where books really flex their artistic muscles over movies. To conjure truly expansive, fantastical settings and high-concept plot lines on the big screen requires blockbuster budgets and pushing the boundaries of special effects. With the written word, you can go as massive and mind-bending as your imagination can fathom without overtaxing a studio’s CGI team.

The cosmic scale and theoretical physics baked into The Three-Body Problem easily make Liu Cixin’s book one of the most bracingly original and outright trippy works of sci-fi I’ve ever experienced. I mean, humanity’s first contact with a truly alien intelligence that defies all our puny assumptions about the nature of reality? Entire dimensions and civilizations existing in different realms of physics and perception? Just try translating that brilliantly weird headiness into a few hours of Hollywood visuals. Good luck!

Novels like The Three-Body Problem remind me that books don’t have the same limitations as movies. No matter how cutting-edge the CGI or A-list the director, films inevitably have to rein in sprawling world-building and high-concept ideas to keep the run time somewhat sane. But writers have the entire infinite space of the imagination to construct mind-bending realms more fantastical than our puny brains could fathom. That freedom opens up entire new dimensions of creativity simply impossible to fully capture on the screen.

The Inner Lives Movies Can’t Reach

Of course, it’s not just the scenery and ideas where novels reign supreme. The true magic of books lies in how they transport you directly into the interior minds and souls of the characters you’re following for those few hundred delicious pages. Sure, actors use tools like body language and line delivery to hint at inner life. But no performance, no matter how talented the thespian, can quite match the raw intimacy of straight-up inner monologue.

Think of any iconic character whose journey you got deliciously, unflinchingly consumed by while turning pages. Holden Caulfield spiraling through his angst-ridden coming-of-age in The Catcher in the Rye . Frankie Addams wrestling with themes of race, gender, and identity in The Member of the Wedding. Raskolnikov’s feverish descent into guilt and moral chaos in Crime and Punishment.

As you followed them chapter by chapter, you were essentially a captive audience to their every fleeting thought, bitter rant, soul-searching rumination, and private struggle with the world spinning around them. Their narrative voice became so distinct and ingrained that by the final pages, you felt like you truly knew these characters on a deeper level than some actual people in your life.

Movies can try their damnedest to expose that interiority, but they’re shooting in the dark compared to books. All they have to work with are carefully calculated cinematography, editing, and whatever psychological magic the actors can mine from the script. It’s all educated guesswork about someone’s inner experience. But books take you straight to the source, allowing you to marinate in a character’s unspoken musings and unpack their every messy motivation from the inside out. That’s soul-binding intimacy no visual medium can quite emulate.

The Writer’s Touch

And then there’s the simple matter of authorial style and literary technique that add so much rich texture and meaning to the very fabric of a good book. I’m talking about the masterful wordsmiths who bend the tools of language – specific phrasings, rhythmic cadences, cultural metaphors, and all the rest – into a signature poetic voice that resonates beyond surface-level storytelling.

Can you even imagine the lyrical verses of Cormac McCarthy or Toni Morrison being adapted to the screen with their essence and subtext intact? Those authors’ poignant yet sparse words about the brutal realities of the American frontier and Black experience are literary languages unto themselves. They evoke layers of emotion and social commentary just through the very stylistic DNA of their prose.

As cinematic as a talented director might try to be, the visual-based nature of moviemaking inevitably strips away those subtle layers of historical echoes and thematic provocations that authors could convey with a single precisely-chosen turn of phrase. Films are wonderful at spectacle and grandeur. But books engage our hearts, minds, and souls through the sheer poetic artistry of language.

On Your Own Schedule

Then there’s the simple pleasure of being able to dictate your own creative journey in a book versus getting dragged along at the predetermined pace of a movies. Have you ever stopped to linger over a lyrical sentence or meaningful passage that hit you right in the soul? Unless you paused that movie, good luck re-reading and meditating on its nuances during the actual screening – you’ll get immediately shunted forward.

Conversely, how many times have you impatiently muttered “Okay, I get it already!” as interminable scenes dragged on long after you were ready to find out what happens next? With a book, you have the luxury of speeding up or slowing down to your own desired pace. Marathon through chapters during thrilling action or suspenseful rises in the plot. Lazily stretch out and bask in the beautiful calmer passages that speak to you.

Having that freedom to dictate your own pacing and focus creates an experience that syncs far more personally with your individual engagement in the moment. It helps you internalize the story and its messages on a deeper, more meaningful level than movie’s one-speed-fits-all structure ever could.

And let’s be real here – half the dang fun of picking up a new book is slowly piecing together tantalizing hints to build anticipation for what’s coming next, right? But movies have a nasty tendency to spoil at least some major plot points through heavy-handed marketing and trailers teasing action sequences that your favorite characters clearly survive. Nothing erodes the thrill of literary suspense and delicious guesswork quite like dramatic third-act previews.

With a good book, you’re left free to build steadily spiraling excitement and theory-crafting about how those subtle character moments or shocking chapter cliffhangers could possibly resolve. And when you finally do turn that no-spoiler final page? Reading allows you to experience the climactic twists and cathartic payoffs in their purest, most viscerally shocking form.

The Companion, Not The Replacement

Listen, I’m not here to claim movies are some big bad evil demolishing the sanctity of literature. At their best, film adaptations can be downright inspiring works of art and storytelling in their own right. Anyone who’s gotten goosebumps at Middle-Earth’s sweeping grandeur in the The Lord of the Rings films or felt genuine chills at the eldritch horror of the Demogorgons in Stranger Things knows the magic that cinema can conjure.

But my core thesis here is simply this: Even the most ambitious and artistically-accomplished of book-to-screen adaptations should be viewed as celebratory companions to the source material, not definitive replacements for it. An adaptation can absolutely put its own clever creative spin on the blueprint while still faithfully capturing its essence and spirit.

However, trying to properly translate an entire author’s deliciously sprawling fictional universe and all its rich thematic underpinnings into a two or three-hour visual narrative will inevitably mean some serious corners get cut. Key characters get shafted for brevity. Complex subplots or details get omitted. Grand ideas and timeless observations about the human condition get watered down or lost entirely in favor of watchable pacing and blockbuster bombast.

So please, grab those movie tickets and have an absolute blast watching the latest beloved book hit the big screen! But don’t make the mistake of assuming you’ve now experienced that story’s full imaginative richness and depths. For that, you’ll need to find a cozy reading nook and rediscover the original tale on your own intimate terms.

If a particularly mind-blowing film adaptation hooked its claws in your imagination, phenomenal! Now pick up the printed version and truly lose yourself in the journey from page one. Savor the author’s subtle genius of character work, wordsmithing, and profound thematic resonance that no director, no matter how talented, could quite capture. Because here’s the simple truth: As immersive and moving as your favorite movies might be, books remain the truest channel for our imaginations to roam unfettered and co-create entire worlds with each empathetic flight into fiction.

So library card or e-reader, whichever your poison, books will forever be the purest and most personal form of transportive storytelling humanity has yet conceived. Their magic quite literally springs eternally from our own creative minds – didn’t you know you were part of the spell all along?

More on this topic

Leave a reply cancel reply.

Sign me up for the newsletter!

Readers also enjoyed

The atlas six by olivie blake, people we meet on vacation by emily henry, the house in the cerulean sea by tj klune, the summer place by jennifer weiner, one italian summer by rebecca serle, lists with this book, buy tiktok views to expand your reach.

Popular stories

Rules and standards for book club, 12 powerful life changing books, characters from fictional world that make connection with you immediately.

The Bookish Elf is your single, trusted, daily source for all the news, ideas and richness of literary life. The Bookish Elf is a site you can rely on for book reviews, author interviews, book recommendations, and all things books. Contact us: [email protected]

Quick Links

• Privacy Policy

Recent Posts

© 2021 tagDiv. All Rights Reserved. Made with Newspaper Theme.

Books Vs. Movies: Similarities and Differences Essay

Books vs. movies – introduction, similarities between books and movies, difference between books and movies, works cited.

This paper examines the similarities and differences between books and movies. Although both tell stories and evoke emotions, they also have distinct characteristics. For example, books rely on the reader’s imagination, while movies present a pre-determined visual interpretation. Another difference between books and movies is that books typically offer a more in-depth exploration of characters, while movies may prioritize visual spectacle over character development. Despite these contrasts, both books and movies have the power to entertain, educate, and inspire. This essay compares and contrasts the two products in detail and provides examples from famous works.

Books and movies are two of the most important mediums for communicating ideas to an audience. The two can be used for various purposes, including entertaining and informing. Books make use of written words to communicate with the reader. On the other hand, movies utilize audio-visual technology to communicate with the viewing audience. Books and Movies have several significant similarities and differences.

A major similarity is that both books and movies set out to tell stories that are often fascinating to the audience. Regardless of which medium is being used, efforts are made to create stories that are going to be engaging to the reader or viewer. For both movies and books, the story is a central part, and the authors or directors come up with themes and plotlines that can captivate and entertain the audience (Bordwell and Staiger 262). By using elements such as characters, setting, conflict, and resolution at the end, book authors and movie directors can come up with successful stories.

Another similarity is that both books and movies make great use of characters through whom the story is told. Bordwell and Staiger note that the characters used must be well suited to the story, and they must be clearly distinguished from one another (262). They are given personalities and used to fulfill the key elements of the story being told through the book or the movie. In most cases, it is the characters that make the audience regard a movie or book as superior or inferior.

A significant difference between books and movies is in the manner in which the visual images are created. When reading a book, the reader has to use his/her imagination to create a visual image from the words contained in the book (Mayer 17). For example, in the Harry Potter books, the reader is required to form his/her own image of the various magical creatures. On the other hand, movies present the reader with a ready visual image. In the Harry Potter Movies, the images of creatures such as trolls and goblins are presented to the audience. The imagination of the viewer is not required since the movie makers have already created the image they want the audience to have.

Books and movies differ in the level of detail provided. In books, the author spends a lot of time providing details of characters, events, objects, and places. These lengthy descriptions are necessary to help the reader to create a mental image of the story. With movies, there are no lengthy details used. Movies do not have to engage in detailed descriptions since a complicated image can be shown in a single movie shot. Mayer notes that a movie can, within the span of a few seconds, graphically show a mass of details to the viewer (17).

Books and movies are both adequate means of telling a story. While the two make use of different technologies to communicate with an audience, they have some similarities. These include the use of stories and the reliance on characters to tell the story. However, the two have major differences in terms of the level of imagination required of the audience and the use of details. Overall, books and movies are important communication mediums that play a great role in our society.

Bordwell, David, and Janet Staiger. The Classical Hollywood Cinema: Film Style and Mode of Production to 1960. NY: Routledge, 2003. Print.

Mayer, Robert. Eighteenth-Century Fiction on Screen . Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2002. Print.

• Chicago (A-D)
• Chicago (N-B)

IvyPanda. (2023, October 29). Books Vs. Movies: Similarities and Differences Essay. https://ivypanda.com/essays/books-vs-movies-similarities-and-differences/

"Books Vs. Movies: Similarities and Differences Essay." IvyPanda , 29 Oct. 2023, ivypanda.com/essays/books-vs-movies-similarities-and-differences/.

IvyPanda . (2023) 'Books Vs. Movies: Similarities and Differences Essay'. 29 October.

IvyPanda . 2023. "Books Vs. Movies: Similarities and Differences Essay." October 29, 2023. https://ivypanda.com/essays/books-vs-movies-similarities-and-differences/.

1. IvyPanda . "Books Vs. Movies: Similarities and Differences Essay." October 29, 2023. https://ivypanda.com/essays/books-vs-movies-similarities-and-differences/.

Bibliography

IvyPanda . "Books Vs. Movies: Similarities and Differences Essay." October 29, 2023. https://ivypanda.com/essays/books-vs-movies-similarities-and-differences/.

• Harry Potter Books and Movies
• The Harry Potter Phenomenon Analysis
• Literary Values of Harry Potter Novels by Rowling
• Gender Role in Harry Potter Books and Movies
• Rowling's “Harry Potter” Books in Connection to Mythology
• The Harry Potter Series
• "Harry Potter" Movie and Novel: Plot Changes
• J. K. Rowling's Harry Potter and Its Popularity
• Harry Potter Stories and Impact on Pop Culture
• Concept of Home in "The Odyssey" and "Harry Potter"
• The New Hollywood Cinema Development
• The Creation of Narrative Films: History and Factors
• The Invention of Cinema at the End of the XIX Century
• Filmmaking History of the USA
• Silent Era vs. Modern Cinema Era

• Craft and Criticism
• Fiction and Poetry
• News and Culture
• Lit Hub Radio
• Reading Lists

• Literary Criticism
• Craft and Advice
• In Conversation
• On Translation
• Short Story
• From the Novel
• Bookstores and Libraries
• Film and TV
• Art and Photography
• Freeman’s
• The Virtual Book Channel
• Behind the Mic
• Beyond the Page
• The Cosmic Library
• The Critic and Her Publics
• Emergence Magazine
• Fiction/Non/Fiction
• First Draft: A Dialogue on Writing
• The History of Literature
• I’m a Writer But
• Lit Century
• Tor Presents: Voyage Into Genre
• Windham-Campbell Prizes Podcast
• Write-minded
• The Best of the Decade
• Best Reviewed Books
• BookMarks Daily Giveaway
• The Daily Thrill
• CrimeReads Daily Giveaway

News, Notes, Talk

Scientific proof that the book is almost always better than the movie.

My dad used to say that most movies are better than most books, and a bad movie is better (or at least easier to sit through) than a bad book, but with the very best books, no movie could even come close. Especially not if it’s the adaptation of that book. “But where’s the data ?” is something I did not say to my father at the tender age of ten. Good thing we now have data that analyzes viewer and reader ratings for 250 books and their adaptations and pretty much confirms what we already knew—that readers like books more than viewers like the movies based on those books—and a handy infographic to go along with it.

Check out the infographic below; you can also explore the data in full here .

[via Broadbandchoices ]

• Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
• Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
• Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
• Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window)
• Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window)
• Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window)
• Click to share on Pocket (Opens in new window)
• Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window)
• Click to print (Opens in new window)

to the Lithub Daily

April 30, 2024.

• Parul Sehgal profiles Judith Butler
• Erin Vanderhoof talks to Claire Messud
• Mid-century sci-fi and fantasy classics by women

Lit hub Radio

• RSS - Posts

Literary Hub

Created by Grove Atlantic and Electric Literature

Sign Up For Our Newsletters

How to Pitch Lit Hub

Advertisers: Contact Us

Privacy Policy

Support Lit Hub - Become A Member

Become a Lit Hub Supporting Member : Because Books Matter

For the past decade, Literary Hub has brought you the best of the book world for free—no paywall. But our future relies on you. In return for a donation, you’ll get an ad-free reading experience , exclusive editors’ picks, book giveaways, and our coveted Joan Didion Lit Hub tote bag . Most importantly, you’ll keep independent book coverage alive and thriving on the internet.

Become a member for as low as $5/month

• International edition
• Australia edition
• Europe edition

Are books better than films?

I went to see Percy Jackson and the Sea of Monsters with the Spinebreakers. We all needed to write something on the film and our views on it. I did my research first. I re-read the book, made numerous notes, wrote down everything I wanted to see in the film and brought a notebook into the cinema with me, ready to jot down my thoughts as the film played out before me.

The film was amazing – seriously, it blew me away. It was so, so much better than its prequel, Percy Jackson and the Lightning Thief, and stuck so much closer to the book – something that obviously made me exceptionally happy.

The people who worked on the film... they got a lot of things right. They got the characters, the world, the creatures, the feel all right. They changed the plot, of course, and missed various things out, adding others in their place. But this didn't matter – Percy Jackson and the Sea of Monsters was absolutely stunning.

So why am I so obsessed with the things they changed? Why am I so much more in love with the book than with the film?

The same thing happened with The Hunger Games. They got almost everything exactly right, but it still... it didn't have the same feel to it. The suspense and emotion just didn't project from page to the screen.

Films... they can do a lot of things. They can bring whole worlds to life before our eyes, make characters into living, breathing flesh and blood. They can have us on the edge of our seats as vicious battle scenes are fought right before us, have us sobbing over a death, a heartbreak or smiling with joy. Films can make us see a lot of things – sometimes things that even books cannot do so well. They are a pure escape – there's nothing like sitting in the cinema, devoid of any other distraction, focused completely on the story playing on the screen.

Films are great, but they just don't have the same...inclusion that books have. You're merely an observer: you aren't feeling everything the character feels, aren't reading every single one of their innermost thoughts, all of their doubts and fears and hopes. Films let you observe everything. Books? Books let you feel everything, know everything and LIVE everything. With a book, you can be the hero who kills the demon with one twirl of your blade. You can be the girl who battles cancer, along with all the pain and uncertainty that comes with it. You can be a demigod, you can be an alien, you can be an angel, a god, a villain, a hero. You can be in love, you can hate, you can triumph, you can lose. You can be anything and everything. There are no limits. No restrictions. Nothing is impossible, nothing is out of reach…

And that… that is why books are always better. When you read a book, nothing else exists and you can be a whole other person in this completely new and amazing world. You can live as someone else, free of your own troubles, even if only for two hundred pages.

Books are magic. Which is why I'm telling you all to forget about movie magic and get back to the pure magic that lives upon your bookshelves. Because while the movies are good… the books are ALWAYS better.

Do you think books are better than films? Send us your thoughts - [email protected] - or join the discussion on Facebook

Your responses

ABitCrazy The thing is... most days people prefer to have a day sitting in front of the television watching the latest films and TV shows; some people even just watch TV for the sake of watching TV and they're willing to watch any old junk. And it's more common to find people that prefer to sit in front of the television all day than it is to find someone that wants to sit at home reading all day. I love reading with a passion; I love letting my imagination run wild and imagining what all these characters look like and how they're feeling. Films don't do that for you but books do! Almost all books that become bestsellers get turned into films and sometimes the films really please you and sometimes it can be soul-destroying!

Two of my favourite series of books have both been turned into films - The Hunger Games and Twilight.

And after watching the first Hunger Games it totally ruined the book for me forever. I can't imagine the Hunger Games the way I used to when I re-read the book. The Hunger Games was somewhere to escape to on a good or bad day; it made you forget where you were and start being a different person, even if it only lasted the length of a book. It felt like it was my life and not Katniss's but now that I've seen the film I no longer imagine how the characters looked and reacted to everything. But watching and reading Twilight didn't feel quite like that, because when Twilight first came out in cinemas I was to young to watch it so I wasn't interested in it but as we all know Twilight is now one of the most popular teen books and movies ever! So once I got to the age of wanting to watch and read the books it was too late to think up my own imagination of the book because by then I had seen and read so many things about Twilight I already knew most of what happened. So films in some ways ruin books for children. And if the Hunger Games turns out like Twilight - all the people that are too young to watch it now but might when they are older will have already seen all the trailers and read all the articles in magazines - the experience of reading the book will be totally ruined for them.

And then you have people that just skip the book and go straight to the film. I understand that some people actually don't like reading so they probably won't read the book but they might watch the film, but to just skip the book completely because they're desperate to watch the film is disappointing. I like to read the books first to know where it all started and why they decided to make a film out of it. I didn't read all of The Host (Stephenie Meyer's other novel) before I saw the film but I did read some of it and it was a great book from what I read but also a great film. And of course sometimes films seem to be the same idea as the book had but are not actually based on the book. So it's a bit like Twilight for instance; Twilight's inspiration came mainly from the American TV show Buffy The Vampire Slayer but had its own little twist. And that's a bit like what films do to books. They make it seem like they've taken the idea from the book but switched it up so it's not actually anything to do with the book.

And for this reason that's why I prefer books to films. Films destroy really amazing books! And TV has changed books. Maybe some people only read books because they're the reason that the films exist and I think that reading a book because of TV and films is a bad way to read; I think people should read a book because they actually want to read the book and every book should be a new story. And of course there are films not related to books at all and books that films aren't based on, and sometimes that is exactly how it should be: sometimes it's best if the two things aren't connected.

• Children's books discussions
• Children and teenagers
• Children's books: 8-12 years
• children's user reviews

Most viewed

7 Reasons Why The Book Is Better Than The Movie

By: Author Laura

Posted on Published: 29th June 2020  - Last updated: 29th February 2024

Categories Books , Film

People always say the book is better than the movie. And most of the time that’s true. Here’s why.

You’ve heard it a thousand times before: The book is better than the movie. Is this just some people’s way of seeming intellectually superior? Or is there something to it?

Let’s talk about the books vs movies argument. 

If you love books, you’ll likely emphatically agree that the book version of any story is superior to the film version.

But sometimes, a great director with a vision gets the film just right. I never liked a film version of Romeo and Juliet until Baz Luhrmann brought it to the big screen.

So let’s jump into the book vs movie argument and look at why some adaptations of books just aren’t successful on the big screen.

If you’re here for inspiration for your book vs movie essay, then these 7 book and movie comparison ideas might help you get started.

Word Play Doesn’t Translate

So much of what makes a book or a story come alive on the page is the use of figurative language and other word play.

Shakespeare’s Romeo and Juliet – technically a play – is often lost to modern audiences because the language just doesn’t translate on screen.

We can hear the cadence of the dialogue, but we can’t fully appreciate the consistent pattern throughout each line of the play, descriptions and all.

Modern audiences also fail to grasp the full meaning of some of the outdated language, so the irony, sarcasm, and other subtle emotions are lost.

Similarly, a book like The Last Temptation of Christ is hard to translate on screen. Much of the beauty of the book is in the richness of its language.

Only plot and dialogue are conveyed on screen, not the metaphor, symbolism, alliteration, and other figurative language.

When you read, you appreciate the masterful choice of language, as well as the particulars of the story.

Some Imagery is Hard to Capture

It seems hard to believe that a visual medium like film would not be able to convey some imagery better than a book, but it’s true.

Some imagery lives more in the realm of a dreamscape. It is surrealistic and blends emotion with visuals, so what you see with your eyes may not be what is meant to be conveyed.

You can see a perfect example of this in the book Beloved , which was made into a movie starring Oprah Winfrey and Thandie Newton.

Much of the book was a blend of magical realism and metaphor, which is very difficult to translate into the visual reality of film.

You have to feel these things, and you can only feel them by actually being there or by being immersed in your own imagination, as suggested by the story.

One of my favourite book vs movie quotes is: 

The book is a film that takes place in the mind of the reader – Paul Coelho

Action is Changed for Drama

When books are adapted, some of the action in the book is changed so that it makes for better drama or better flow in a movie.

For example, when the book The Never-Ending Story starts, we meet Atreyu in his own land. In the movie, we first meet him in the Ivory Tower, which helps start the action faster.

However, the book shows Bastian’s dad grieving the loss of his wife, not Bastian himself. The book depicts Bastian as more lonely at the start, and his journey is a more satisfying one than in the movie.

In the book The Wizard of Oz , there are additional characters, like the Queen of the Field Mice, who rescues the Cowardly Lion from the Poppy Field.

She’s cut from the movie to streamline the cast of characters and the action, but she adds a little something extra in the book.

Books Have No Limit

When reading a book, you are free to read at your own pace and enjoy the story in your own time.

Some books are only one hundred pages long but others could be up to a thousand pages. And people still read both.

However, movies are limited to a two hour slot where they can capture people’s attention.

Anywhere between one and a half hours and two and a half hours seems to be the norm for a film and if they can’t fit all the elements of the plot into that time (and they never will), then they inevitably end up cutting corners and simplifying characters and plot lines.

As such a film adaptation will never have all the details that a reader desires and many end up disappointed when entire scenes and characters end up cut from the film.

The trend of splitting movie adaptations into two halves does nothing to help matters either.

With Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows , two films still wasn’t enough. With The Hobbit , three films was too excessive and yet it still didn’t convey everything from the books.

Actors aren’t How You Imagined

The movies might cast actors who don’t look the way you imagined the characters would look, which can often be a very difficult thing to look past.

A common issue in Hollywood is whitewashing the cast and, more recently, forced diversity.

The problem with the former is obvious – if the book is set in a foreign country with foreign characters but is given an all white cast when it’s adapted for the screen then this is wrong, wrong, wrong .

They did this with the Netflix movie adaptation of the manga  Death Note and the film received huge amounts of backlash as a result.

On the other hand, the film Crazy Rich Asians has received lots of praise for sticking to an all Asian cast for this book to film adaptation.

If that doesn’t prove to Hollywood the importance of staying as true to the book as possible when it comes to casting then I don’t know what does. 

Conversely, forced diversity can negatively impact a book to film adaptation as well. J K Rowling’s works have been accused of forced diversity in Hollywood.

Casting a Black Hermione, Korean Nagini and gay Dumbledore have all been branded desperate attempts tick the “diversity” box.

Many fans of Harry Potter and Fantastic Beasts have criticised Rowling for trying to retrospectively claim that her works do include lots of diverse characters.

Actors aren’t up to Scratch

Further to the point above, even if an actor looks the part, they might fail to truly translate their character from page to screen.

A books show the inner thoughts of the characters, which shows their feelings and motivations, and these things can be lost in the movies when the actors aren’t up to scratch.

Take Keanu Reaves in the 1992 film adaptation of Dracula. He plays vampire hunter Jonathan Harker but everything about him is wrong for this role, most notably, his accent.

Or Ginny Weasley in the Harry Potter films ; she’s just a bit flat, isn’t she? We could be here all day discussing Harry Potter book vs movie. 

Money, money, money

Whilst a publisher will be on the lookout for stories to move, to thrill and to absorb the reader, the top priority in film production is  money .

An easy way to make sure they get people to the cinema so that money starts rolling in is to cast people that are beautiful and famous and create bigger bangs.

Usually at the expense of accurate storytelling.

This is why some book to film adaptations take nothing but the bare bones of the book plot before being turned into a theatrical drama that barely resembles the original copy. 

And that’s it for my book vs movie comparison! There are a lot of other things that movies can do to the stories from your favourite books that make them less satisfying.

There’s definitely something to it when people say that the book is better than the movie, but the reasons can vary.

But that doesn’t mean that the movie is never as good as the book.

We’ve seen some great adaptations of some great books and I will admit that I actually prefer the Lord of the Rings films to the books. Shh . 

What are some of your favourite book to film adaptations?

Pin now, read again later!

If you liked this post, check out these: Ultimate List of Movie Night Essentials The Perfect Movie for Any Occasion Reasons to Always Carry a Book With You How I Read 75+ Books a Year 45 Quotes About Bookworms Paperback vs Hardback Books

Editor of What’s Hot?

This article was first published in 2017 and updated in 2020.

Jasswinder singh

Tuesday 31st of August 2021

I built my self only from the books Movie stops your visualization power Where books inbuilt your imagination power

Monday 29th of March 2021

What total poppycock! Both the author of this nonsense and the commenters above apparently fancy themselves as culturally superior to those who find movies vastly superior to book tales - in most cases. Obviously anyone who has read a novel prior to going to see the movie version has already learned the path of the story being told. Movie goers are not subject to investing hours and days on a written tome only to discover the author is indeed substandard. Even with books by accomplished authors many movies produced far outshine the written work - The Godfather I & II, Gone With the Wind, Inherit the Wind, To Kill a Mockingbird are just a few movies superior to the best seller written versions.

Koyel Murmu

Friday 26th of February 2021

Thank you so much! I have an assignment on a similar topic and you just saved me <3

Friday 11th of September 2020

So true! Great breakdown of why books are almost always better! I recently started a blog where I compare books and movies, maybe you would find it interesting whythebookwins.com

Wednesday 28th of June 2017

I have yet to find a movie that beats the book for me. It's always the casting that ruins it for me though. By the time I'm done reading, I'm emotionally invested in the characters and the plot, so when the cast and plot don't match what the book reads like to me, it drives me mad haha. Great post!

10 Reasons Why Are Books Better Than Movies

There’s no doubt that movies are a dominant form of entertainment these days. They seem to be constantly evolving and getting more and more complex, with higher production values and bigger budgets. However, there’s one problem with movies: they’re not books. Books have been around for centuries, and they show no signs of going away. In fact, books are better than movies in many ways.

Table of Contents

Are movies better than books?

There are a lot of people who would say that movies are better than books. After all, movies provide an experience that is more immediate and visceral than reading a book. They can be more exciting, and they can take you to worlds that you could never visit in real life.

However, there are also a lot of people who would say that books are better than movies. Books can provide a more in-depth and nuanced experience than movies can, and they can often be more emotionally powerful. They can also be more intellectually stimulating, teaching you things that you could never learn from a movie.

Ultimately, it’s up to each individual to decide which is better: books or movies. However, it’s hard to deny that both have their own unique benefits and drawbacks.

In this post, we will talk about why books are better than movies but before that, let’s not forget about the good things movies offer and why movies are better than books(in some aspects).

Why Movies Are Better Than Books?

There are a few reasons why movies are better than books.

First, movies are visual. You can see the characters and the setting, and it’s all in one place. With a book, you have to imagine everything yourself.

Second, movies are more exciting. They have music and sound effects, and they move quickly.

Third, movies are more social. You can watch them with other people and talk about them.

Fourth, movies are easier to understand. You don’t have to read the book to know what’s going on.

These are the reasons stand out for movies over books.

Why Are Books Better Than Movies?

Now let’s move into the benefits of reading books over movies. Here are a few reasons why books are better than movies.

Books provide a more in-depth and well-rounded experience than movies

Books allow readers to use their imaginations and create their own images instead of being restricted to what is shown on the screen. This also means that books can be interpreted in different ways, depending on the reader’s perspective, while movies are generally more one-dimensional.

Books also allow for a greater level of detail than movies. For example, a book can describe a character’s appearance in great detail, while a movie would only be able to show a snapshot of that character. Books can also explore complex topics and ideas that movies cannot handle.

Books can be paused, reread, and analyzed more thoroughly than movies

One of the biggest advantages that books have over movies is that they can be paused. This may not seem like a big deal, but it actually allows for a lot more analysis and reflection. For example, when watching a movie, if something confusing or surprising happens, you only have a few seconds to try and figure out what’s going on before it moves on(In case you are watching a movie in a theater). With a book, you can take your time to digest what’s happening and think about how it fits into the rest of the story.

Additionally, books tend to be more analytical than movies. This is because books are often slower-paced and allow for more description. Movies, on the other hand, are more action-packed and rely more on visuals. As a result, books often provide a more in-depth look at characters and plotlines than movies do.

Books Allow for Imagination

Movies are a visual medium. They show you what the director wants you to see. They are limited by what is possible on screen. With books, your imagination is engaged. You can see anything in your head that you want to. This leads to a more personal experience with the story. As a result, readers can create their own images in their minds based on the author’s description.

Books can be more detailed

Books are more detailed than movies. This means that readers can get a better understanding of the story and all of its intricacies. In movies, it’s often difficult to fit in all of the necessary details, which can leave viewers feeling confused.

There are a lot of movie adaptations of books where you will feel like the movie isn’t much detailed compared to the books you read.

Books have pages after pages to explore a topic, while movies are limited by the runtime. This means that readers can learn more about the story and the characters. In addition, books allow for more complex storylines and character development, which isn’t always possible in a movie.

Books can be interpreted differently

Every person who reads a book will interpret it differently. This is due to the number of different perspectives that books offer. With movies, it’s often more difficult to create a variety of interpretations due to the visual nature of the storytelling. This means that people may not have as much of an opportunity to connect with a movie on a personal level.

Books can stay with you for a long time

Movies come and go. You might see a movie once and never think about it again. But a book can stay with you for a long time. You can keep rereading it, thinking about it, and getting something new out of it every time.

So, books can stay with you for a long time. Most of the time, when you watch a movie you might forget about it within a few days. But a good book will stick with you for weeks, months, or even years.

Stories can be ruined by bad acting

One of the biggest problems with movies is that they can be ruined by bad acting. Actors can completely change the feel of a story through their poor performances.

This is not a problem with books, as the reader can always imagine the characters in their own way.

Books improve your vocabulary

Books can improve your vocabulary. Sure, you can learn new words from movies too, but there’s something about reading that makes them stick in your mind better. A lot of time, books will use words that you wouldn’t hear in everyday conversation. This is a great way to improve your vocabulary and learn new words!

Movies focus more on being commercial and compromise on quality

Books are more likely to be focused on telling a good story and providing exciting and valuable content rather than trying to make a quick buck. This is because books don’t rely on box office sales in order to make money – they can be sold at any time to any customer. Therefore, the focus can be on the story and the content rather than on trying to make the movie as flashy and commercial as possible. This often means that movies are more likely to compromise on quality in order to cram in more commercial elements.

For example, a movie might have a shorter running time in order to fit in more advertisements, or it might use well-known actors who might not be the best choice for the role. In contrast, a book is unlikely to have these same commercial pressures, so it can take time to develop the characters and the story. This often leads to a more satisfying experience for the reader.

Movies have limited storytelling time

Movies have a limited storytelling time. It’s not possible to put all the details of the book in a two hours movie. Hence, movies can miss out a lot of good parts because of it’s limited time.

On the other hand, books do not have any limited time to read. It depends on the reader how fast they can read.

A book can be picked up and put down, again and again, allowing the reader to take their time in consuming the story. Books allow for the imagination to run wild, picturing the characters and scenes in any way possible. This is not to say that movies are not powerful, but books allow for a more personal connection with the story.

Other reasons:

Books are more likely to lead to discussions than movies.

One of the great things about books is that they can lead to discussions. When you’re watching a movie, it’s a passive experience — you watch, and then you move on. But with a book, there are different interpretations, and people can have different reactions. This can lead to some really interesting conversations.

Books can provide new insights with each reading

Whereas movies are typically watched just once, books can be read multiple times and provide new insights with each reading. This is due to the level of detail that books can provide as well as their ability to allow readers to interpret the text in their own way.

In contrast, movies are limited by what can be shown on screen and cannot provide the same level of detail as a book. As a result, movies may not always provide an accurate portrayal of the story that is being told.

Conclusion:

Though movies can be great, they often cannot compare to the experience of reading a book. Books allow for more immersion in the story and can provide a richer experience because readers can visualize what is happening in their minds.

Additionally, books tend to have better storylines and characters than movies do. For these reasons, I believe that books are better than movies. Have you ever read a book that was better than a movie? Let me know in the comments.

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment.

Want to create or adapt books like this? Learn more about how Pressbooks supports open publishing practices.

55 Writing about the Novel: Film Comparison

You began the process of writing your literary comparison paper in the Introduction to the Novel chapter by choosing an essay, reading it carefully, and writing a personal response. In this chapter, we will move through the remaining steps of writing your paper.

Step 3: Choose a Film for Comparison

The key to a good comparison essay is to choose two subjects that connect in a meaningful way. The purpose of conducting the comparison is not to state the obvious, but rather to illuminate subtle differences or unexpected similarities.

When writing a film comparison paper, the point is to make an argument that will make your audience think about your topic in a new and interesting way. You might explore how the novel and the film present the theme…or how the novel and the film explore the identity of a main character…or…the options are limitless. Here’s a quick video giving you a little overview of what a film vs novel comparison might look like:

To this end, your next goal is to choose a film adaptation of your novel. Some novels may only have one, but some have many that have been created over the last 100 years! Your adaptation could be a feature film, a YouTube short, or an indie film. Choose one that allows you to make an interesting point about the portrayal of the theme of the novel and the film.

Step 4: Research

Once you’ve chosen a second piece, it’s time to enter into the academic conversation to see what others are saying about the authors and the pieces you’ve chosen.

Regardless of the focus of your essay, discovering more about the author of the text you’ve chosen can add to your understanding of the text and add depth to your argument. Author pages are located in the Literature Online ProQuest database. Here, you can find information about an author and his/her work, along with a list of recent articles written about the author. This is a wonderful starting point for your research.

The next step is to attempt to locate articles about the text and the film themselves. For novels, it’s important to narrow down your database choices to the Literature category. For essays, you might have better luck searching the whole ProQuest library with the ProQuest Research Library Article Databases or databases like Flipster that include publications like newspapers and magazines.

Finally, you might look for articles pertinent to an issue discussed in the novel. For example, The Grapes of Wrath is about the Great Depression and the Dust Bowl, but it also contains an environmental theme. Depending on what aspect you want to highlight in your comparison, you might look for articles about the Great Depression or about farming and the environment.

Remember, it is helpful to keep a Research Journal to track your research. Your journal should include, at a minimum, the correct MLA citation of the source, a brief summary of the article, and any quotes that stick out to you. A note about how you think the article adds to your understanding of the topic or might contribute to your project is a good addition, as well.

Step 5: Thesis & Outline

Similar to other academic essays, the film comparison essay starts with a thesis that clearly introduces the two subjects that are to be compared and the reason for doing so.

This video highlights some of the key differences between novels and films:

Begin by deciding on your basis for comparison. The basis of comparison could include items like a similar theme, differences in the focus of the piece, or the way both pieces represent an important issue.

This article gives some helpful advice on choosing a topic.

Once you’ve decided on the basis of comparison, you should focus on the points of comparison between the two pieces. For example, if you are focusing on how the literary elements and the cinematic elements used impact the message, you might make a table of each of these elements. Then, you’d find examples of each element from each piece. Remember, a comparison includes both similarities and differences.

By putting together your basis of comparison and your points of comparison, you’ll have a thesis that both makes an argument and gives readers a map of your essay.

A good thesis should be:

• Statement of Fact: “The novel and the film of Pride and Prejudice are similar in many ways.”
• Arguable: “The film version of Pride and Prejudice changes key moments in the text that alter the portrayal of the theme.”
• Personal Opinion: “‘The novel is definitely better than the movie.”
• Provable by the Texts: “Both the novel and the film focus on the importance of identity.”
• Obvious: “The movie provides a modern take on the novel.”
• Surprising: “Though the movie stays true to the original themes of the novel, the modern version may lead viewers to believe that the characters in the book held different values than are portrayed in the novel.”
• General: “Both the novel and the film highlight the plight of women.”
• Specific: “The novel and the film highlight the plight of women by focusing on specific experiences of the protagonist. “

The organizational structure you choose depends on the nature of the topic, your purpose, and your audience. You may organize compare-and-contrast essays in one of the following two ways:

• Block: Organize topics according to the subjects themselves, discussing the novel and then the film.
• Woven: Organize according to individual points, discussing both the novel and the film point by point.

Exercises: Create a Thesis and Outline

You’ll want to start by identifying the theme of both pieces and deciding how you want to tie them together. Then, you’ll want to think through the points of similarity and difference in the two pieces.

In two columns, write down the points that are similar and those that are different. Make sure to jot down quotes from the two pieces that illustrate these ideas.

Following the tips in this section, create a thesis and outline for your novel/film comparison paper.

Here’s a sample thesis and outline:

Step 6: Drafting Tips

Once you have a solid thesis and outline, it’s time to start drafting your essay. As in any academic essay, you’ll begin with an introduction. The introduction should include a hook that connects your readers to your topic. Then, you should introduce the topic. In this case, you will want to include the authors and title of the novel and the director and title of the film. Finally, your introduction should include your thesis. Remember, your thesis should be the last sentence of your introduction.

In a film comparison essay, you may want to follow your introduction with background on both pieces. Assume that your readers have at least heard of either the novel or the film, but that they might not have read the novel or watched the film–or both–…or maybe it’s been awhile. For example, if you were writing about Pride and Prejudice , you might include a brief introduction to Austen and her novel and an introduction to the version of the film you’ve chosen. The background section should be no more than two short paragraphs.

In the body of the paper, you’ll want to focus on supporting your argument. Regardless of the organizational scheme you choose, you’ll want to begin each paragraph with a topic sentence. This should be followed by the use of quotes from your two texts in support of your point. Remember to use the quote formula–always introduce and explain each quote and the relationship to your point! It’s very important that you address both literary pieces equally, balancing your argument. Finally, each paragraph should end with a wrap up sentence that tells readers the significance of the paragraph.

Here are some transition words that are helpful in tying points together:

Finally, your paper will end with a conclusion that brings home your argument and helps readers to understand the importance/significance of your essay.

In this video, an instructor explains step by step how to write an essay comparing two films. Though you will be writing about a novel and a film, rather than two films, the same information applies.

Here’s another instructor explaining how to write a comparison essay about two poems. Note the similarities between the two videos.

Here’s a sample paper:

Attributions:

• Content created by Dr. Karen Palmer. Licensed under CC BY NC SA .
• Content adapted from “Comparison and Contrast” from the book Successful Writing licensed CC BY NC SA .

The Worry Free Writer Copyright © 2020 by Dr. Karen Palmer is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License , except where otherwise noted.

Share This Book

25,000+ students realised their study abroad dream with us. Take the first step today

Meet top uk universities from the comfort of your home, here’s your new year gift, one app for all your, study abroad needs, start your journey, track your progress, grow with the community and so much more.

Verification Code

An OTP has been sent to your registered mobile no. Please verify

Thanks for your comment !

Our team will review it before it's shown to our readers.

• Speech Writing /

Speech on Why Books are Better Than Movies?

• Updated on  
• Dec 22, 2023

What would be your choice – Detailed information, character development, intricate plots, or just some animation on screen? Arguments for and against the idea that books are better than movies depend on the individual.

Johannes Gutenberg, a German Goldsmith, invented the printing press in 1436, which paved the way for publishing books. Today, more than 100 million books exist in multiple fields. Books are often considered our best friend because of the knowledge they offer us. In recent years, there has been a debate on ‘Whether are books better than movies, what can we learn from books which movies lack, etc.’ Today, we will provide you with a speech on why books are better than their movies.

10 Lines on Books Are Better Than Movies

Here are 10 lines on why books are better than movies. Feel free to use them in your school topics.

• Books offer an extensive exploration of characters, providing in-depth insights into their thoughts, feelings, and backgrounds.
• Reading books allows us to personalize and imagine experiences.
• Reading books helps us to visualize scenes and characters according to our interpretations and preferences.
• The literary format allows authors to delve into intricate details, nuanced emotions, and complex plots that may be challenging to convey in a condensed movie format.
• Books empower us to use our creativity, filling in gaps and envisioning the story in our minds, fostering a deeper connection to the narrative.
• Books offer a more leisurely and comprehensive exploration of the story, subplots, and character arcs.
• Internal dialogues and character introspection are more effectively conveyed in books.
• Books provide a richer understanding of the character’s motivations and growth throughout the narrative.
• The reader has the flexibility to pause, reflect, and return to any part of the story, 
• Books foster a more immersive and contemplative reading experience.

Books are better than movies because you design the set the way you want it to look pic.twitter.com/pImXogDi0i — MobiQuotes (@mobiquotes) December 20, 2023

2-Minute Speech on Books Are Better Than Movies

‘Good morning my classmates and teacher. Today, I would like to express my speech on why books are better than movies. From our imagination to language skills, books offer a more comprehensive understanding of the subject. Books provide us with detailed information, character development, and complicated plots.’

‘Reading the written words allows us a deep exploration of the character’s thoughts, emotions, and motivation that is more challenging to convey through a movie. We can visualize the character through our imaginations. Books can delve into the internal thoughts and monologues of characters, providing insights into their minds.’

‘The visualization power offered by books does not judge characters based on their looks, something which movies do. In a movie, only a selected character can play a role, but in books, no such thing exists.’

‘As readers, we can control the pace at which we want to consume a story. we can linger over a beautifully written passage, reread sections for better understanding, or skip ahead if we are eager to know what happens next. Movies, on the other hand, have a fixed pace set by the director and editors.’

‘Movies have time constraints because of which certain elements of a story are omitted or skipped. Reading books requires active mental participation, as we need to interpret the text, imagine the scenes, and connect the dots.’

‘Books can offer multiple perspectives, internal dialogues, and diverse narrative styles that may not be as easily conveyed in a visual medium. 

‘Books possess a transformative power, which moves lack. This power goes beyond time and technology, through which we can embark on our personal growth, self-discovery and exploration.’

‘Whether we are reading academic or non-academic books, it’s always a great experience to understand it from our perspective. Whether books are better than movies depends on individual preferences, and both mediums have their strengths and unique ways of storytelling.

Thank you.’

Ans: Books offer in-depth details about the characters, their personalities, thoughts, emotions, and background. Almost every movie has time constraints, where we are required to finish it in the given time frame. On the other hand, books offer us the flexibility to read anything and anywhere. To watch movies, we need proper resources like a TV, laptop or cell phone with an internet connection. Books are easy to carry and don’t need any resources.

Ans: Books keep our minds active and engaged, and offer is diverse range of words and expressions which enhance our vocabulary. Reading books reduces stress levels, improves focus and concentration, enhances imagination and creativity, etc.

Ans: Books provide us with detailed information, character development, and complicated plots. Reading the written words allows us a deep exploration of the character’s thoughts, emotions, and motivation which is more challenging to convey through a movie. We can visualize the character through our imaginations. Books can delve into the internal thoughts and monologues of characters, providing insights into their minds.

Related Articles

For more information on such interesting speech topics for your school, visit our speech writing page and follow Leverage Edu .

Shiva Tyagi

With an experience of over a year, I've developed a passion for writing blogs on wide range of topics. I am mostly inspired from topics related to social and environmental fields, where you come up with a positive outcome.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment.

Contact no. *

Connect With Us

25,000+ students realised their study abroad dream with us. Take the first step today.

Resend OTP in

Need help with?

Study abroad.

UK, Canada, US & More

IELTS, GRE, GMAT & More

Scholarship, Loans & Forex

Country Preference

New Zealand

Which English test are you planning to take?

Which academic test are you planning to take.

Not Sure yet

When are you planning to take the exam?

Already booked my exam slot

Within 2 Months

Want to learn about the test

Which Degree do you wish to pursue?

When do you want to start studying abroad.

January 2024

September 2024

What is your budget to study abroad?

How would you describe this article ?

Please rate this article

We would like to hear more.

Have something on your mind?

Make your study abroad dream a reality in January 2022 with

India's Biggest Virtual University Fair

Essex Direct Admission Day

Why attend .

Don't Miss Out

• Frequently Asked Questions
• Join HS Insider

About                   FAQs                       Join

Arts and Entertainment

Why books are better than movies.

Ivette Gonzalez

Most of the time books are better than movies. Books can let you imagine the setting or events happening in the story. They are also more detailed than movies because movies sometimes leave out some important details.

In some movies, they switch up the characters because in the book they are different and totally the opposite.

When we read a book, we tend to visualize the characters a certain way and in movies they don’t look like the way we want them too. It disappoints us in many ways. I’ve read books before that have a plot twist at the end and in the movie it never happens.

Movies tend to last about two hours and books take their time and last longer. Movies rush things so that they can end it fast and there. Not everyone has access to movies or can afford going to movie theatres but books can be borrowed at the library or from a friend.

Books are portable and can be read online as well, anytime. When reading books, we get more knowledge and it helps us improve our vocabulary. Characters are described much better and with more detail.

One important thing that books do have and movies don’t is that they provide more background information than a movie does.

Visual Credits: reallylaterviews.com

Review: Girls State — Demanding comparison

by Hugo Chiasson | Arts and Entertainment , Opinion

"Girls State" (2024), directed by Jesse Moss and Amanda McBaine, is a necessary companion piece to the 2020’s "Boys State" by the same directors. For its tonal shift away from the political thriller style of the first documentary, to a broader consideration of the...

Column: Second Language Struggles

by Karina Yue | Education , Featured , Schools

I took four years of Mandarin at school, but I can barely speak or understand it. Ironic remarks similar to these are, unfortunately, a common occurrence made by second language learners across learning platforms like Quora and Reddit. While we might jump to...

Pool play: Alex Davies leaves legacy on his way to new heights

by Evan Yao | Features , Sports

Down by the Chadwick Pool, the record board marks the names of extraordinary swimmers who have left remarkable legacies during their careers at the school. One name stands out, particularly with his back-to-back accolades: senior and Chadwick varsity swim captain Alex...

Discover more from HS Insider

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Type your email…

Continue reading

• Search Please fill out this field.
• Manage Your Subscription
• Give a Gift Subscription
• BHG Archives
• Newsletters
• Sweepstakes

Book vs. Movie: A Survey Settles the Debate Over Which Is Better

The results also reveal the most-watched film adaptation.

As a child, reading was one of my favorite activities, and it still is to this day. I've always loved immersing myself in the pages of a novel, entirely captivated by fictional characters and their stories. One part of the experience that almost always left me disappointed, however, was when one of my beloved books became a movie. And according to a recent survey, I'm not the only person who is let down by book adaptations.

SuperSummary , an online resource that provides study guides for fiction and nonfiction books, wanted to know the answer to a burning question: Book or movie? The company asked 2,030 people, ages 23 to 62, to answer questions about books that had been turned into movies or TV shows.

The results were fairly close. Overall, 34% of people enjoyed the book, compared to 27% who preferred the movie. Although 82% of those surveyed agreed that "screen adaptations help books come to life," 46% of people argued that film adaptations "would never be as good as the book." Almost 25% declared that movies even ruined the original book. The top three books that people preferred over the films were: The Da Vinci Code with 53.9%, The Chronicles of Narnia series with 52%, and the Fifty Shades trilogy with 47.3%.

The top reasons for not approving the film adaptation weren't surprising. Nearly 32% said that the movie was too different than the book, 13.4% of people said the film lacked key details, and a little more than 10% of those surveyed didn't like the approximate two-hour movie time limit.

Although respondents were divided on whether they prefer reading vs. watching, they were more aligned with the most-watched adaptation. Forrest Gump took home the top spot, with 76.9% of people saying they've seen it. However, only 5.6% of people said they enjoyed the book. Following was the Jurassic Park series with 74.8%, Charlie and the Chocolate Factory with 73.7%, and the Harry Potter series with 70.1%.

Perhaps the slight preference of the book over the movie is related to libraries being a little more popular than movie theaters . I completely understand why people might prefer watching a live, condensed version of a story on the big screen, but to me, there are few simpler pleasures than getting lost in the pages of a good book.

Related Articles

7 Books That Were Better Than Their Movie Adaptations

I t’s a reader’ s rite of passage to walk into a movie theater to see a favorite book come to life and walk out bitterly disappointed. Sometimes, there’s no softening the truth: what you read on the page is so much better than what you watched on the screen. Here, seven beloved books that are undoubtedly better than their film adaptations .

Ella Enchanted by Gail Carson Levine

Passionate fans of this young adult classic will agree that a true film adaptation of Ella Enchanted does not yet exist. Levine’s 1997 retelling of Cinderella , which earned a prestigious Newbery Honor, was adapted for the screen in 2004, with Anne Hathaway in the starring role. But the movie took significant liberties with Levine’s original plot, adding characters and excluding beloved scenes. The moods of the film and the book feel disparate. As David Rooney wrote in Variety , “The filmmakers also pushed the tone into a far more jokey comic realm, which dilutes the romantic-magical chemistry of the book, downplaying its central idea of a ‘Cinderella’ overhaul.”

The Giver by Lois Lowry

This dystopian young-adult novel has fascinated readers for over 25 years. The Giver tells the story of 12-year-old Jonas, who inhabits a society that lives by the principle of “Sameness,” favoring equality over individuality. The book has been widely celebrated, winning the 1994 Newbery Medal and appearing on school reading lists across the country. But the 2014 film adaptation missed the mark. Despite a notable cast, including Jeff Bridges, Meryl Streep and Taylor Swift, the movie failed to win over audiences in the same way the novel did. Released during a torrent of young adult dystopian adaptations including The Hunger Games and Divergent , The Giver echoed the same themes of young heroes and heroines rising up against society, but added little to the genre.

The Scarlet Letter by Nathaniel Hawthorne

This 1850 work of historical fiction about the Puritan Massachusetts Bay Colony in the 1640s has inspired a number of adaptations to film, page and stage, but the most bizarre of these may be the 1995 film starring Demi Moore, Gary Oldman and Robert Duvall. It was labeled “trashy and nonsensical” by Caryn James in the New York Times , and is frequently disparaged for changing much of the source material, including the ending. Receiving a shockingly low score of 13% on Rotten Tomatoes, this movie took home the award for the Worst Remake or Sequel at the 1995 Golden Raspberry Awards.

The Glass Castle by Jeannette Walls

Walls’ incredible 2005 memoir tells the story of her dysfunctional upbringing: she and her three siblings suffered through turbulent years in a house afflicted with poverty, alcoholism and violence at the hands of their parents. The 2017 movie adaptation was praised for its impressive performances by Brie Larson as the author and Woody Harrelson as her father, Rex, but was criticized for sanitizing the gritty parts of this powerful story, like the grotesque and unsafe conditions Walls and her siblings experienced as children. “The film keeps selling easy uplift even in a coda featuring Walls and her real parents when it most needs to generate raw emotion and blunt truth,” Peter Travers wrote for Rolling Stone .

The Golden Compass by Philip Pullman

The Golden Compass , published in 1995, is the first novel in the beloved young-adult fantasy series, His Dark Materials , a magical story set in a parallel universe. This first part of the trilogy follows a young girl named Lyra as she embarks on a rescue mission to the Arctic. The widely panned 2007 film took five years to complete, slowed down by disagreements over the script and the direction. The studio bought the rights to the trilogy in 2002 and commissioned Tom Stoppard to write the screenplay. Chris Weitz was hired to direct. But Stoppard’s script was rejected and Weitz was fired. In his place, the studio hired Anand Tucker to direct, though Tucker resigned in 2006. Then Weitz returned to write the screenplay and direct the project. The result was a disappointing (and extremely expensive) movie that cut or changed many elements of the novel.

The Lovely Bones by Alice Sebold

This bestselling novel from 2002 tells the story of a teenage girl who is raped and murdered and watches her family grieve from heaven. The 2009 film adaptation boasts terrific performances by Saoirse Ronan and Stanley Tucci as the girl and her attacker, but has little else to offer. The fine balance of sentiment and violence that Sebold strikes in the novel is lost in the movie. The film “strikes clashing tones, veering from lightheartedness to heavy-handedness,” Claudia Puig wrote in USA Today , adding that the device of main character narrating from heaven “works on the page [but] comes off artificial and emotionless on-screen.”

The Girl on the Train by Paula Hawkins

Paula Hawkins’ 2015 thriller was an instant bestseller, heralded as the next Gone Girl . It tells the twisty story of an alcoholic woman who becomes obsessed with a seemingly perfect couple she spots from the window of a train she rides each day, only to be dragged into a police investigation when the wife goes missing. The 2016 film, starring an impressive Emily Blunt, feels more like melodrama than thriller. Blunt’s performance was highly praised , but the film doesn’t rise to her level. “Blunt gives Rachel multiple dimensions — we could never view her as just a stewy mess,” TIME’s Stephanie Zacharek wrote. “But the movie’s surprise (or perhaps not-so-surprising) twist doesn’t serve its lead character well, at best merely justifying her stalkerish behavior.”

More Must-Reads From TIME

• The 100 Most Influential People of 2024
• Coco Gauff Is Playing for Herself Now
• Scenes From Pro-Palestinian Encampments Across U.S. Universities
• 6 Compliments That Land Every Time
• If You're Dating Right Now , You're Brave: Column
• The AI That Could Heal a Divided Internet
• Fallout Is a Brilliant Model for the Future of Video Game Adaptations
• Want Weekly Recs on What to Watch, Read, and More? Sign Up for Worth Your Time

Contact us at [email protected]

2 Minute Speech On Why Books Are Better Than Movies In English

Good morning to everyone in this room. I would like to thank the principal, the teachers, and my dear friends for allowing me to speak to you today about why books are better than movies. In most cases, books are superior to movies. Reading a book might help you visualize the scene or the actions taking place. They are also more thorough than movies, which can skip important facts. Some movies change the characters since they are completely different and the reverse in the novel.

The characters in a book often appear different from how we see them in our minds, and the same is evident in movies. It let us down in a lot of ways. I’ve read books previously with a surprising twist at the conclusion, but the movie never includes it.

Books take their time and are lengthier in length than movies, which typically run two hours. Movies hurry things up so they can get to the finish quickly. Books can be borrowed from a friend or the library if you don’t have access to them or the money to go to the movies.

Books may be read anywhere and at any time online. We get more information and develop our vocabulary when we read books. Character descriptions are significantly more accurate and thorough. Books contain more background information than movies do, which is an important feature that movies lack. Thank you.

Related Posts:

• Howl Poem By Allen Ginsberg Summary, Notes and Line by Line Explanation in English
• Random Compound Word Generator
• How to Summarise a Youtube Video: 6 Easy Steps
• How to Start the First Chapter of a Book?
• A Grammarian's Funeral by Robert Browning Summary
• Random Funny Joke Generator [with Answers]

10 Movies That Were Better Than the Book, According to Reddit

S ince the earliest days of cinema, filmmakers have found inspiration in books, from classic literature to comic books. While there have been plenty of examples where the film adaptation doesn't even come close to matching the book it was based on, there have been times when the movie goes above and beyond its source material.

The question of film adaptations that exceed the quality of the books they were based on was put to the r/AskReddit community, and it garnered an array of fascinating responses. Covering everything from iconic fantasy adventures to crime classics, timeless horror movies, and even Academy Award-winning dramas, these 10 films were improvements on their books in the eyes of Reddit users.

'Stand by Me' (1986)

A common trend through the subreddit was Redditors picking out exceptional movies based on already great books. Perhaps none embody that notion quite so accurately as Stand By Me , a classic coming-of-age drama that adapted Stephen King's The Body for the screen in a manner that delighted not only fans but the author himself .

Following a group of boys venturing into the woods to peer at a dead body, the film is celebrated as one of the most perfect adaptations the screen has ever seen. That sentiment was shared by many Redditors, with chernygal commenting, "The story is great, but the movie just DOES something to me."

'Fight Club' (1999)

A raw and sinister hit of violence and anti-consumerism, Fight Club remains every bit as gripping today as it was upon release. David Fincher's adaptation leans heavily on its source material, following an unnamed protagonist who has insomnia and meets the mysterious Tyler Durden ( Brad Pitt ) and creates an underground fighting club.

The big difference which led Reddit to favor the film over the book concerned the Tyler Durden character and how Pitt portrayed him. Racebannon64 highlighted this by saying, "Brad Pitt brought a level of charisma to Tyler that he doesn't have in the book. In the book, Tyler isn't likable at all." A similar point was made by fade_like_a_sigh, who preferred how Durden is used in the film to manipulate and trick audiences and the narrator.

'The Princess Bride' (1987)

An enduring fantasy classic that has transcended generations with its action, comedy, excitement, and romance, The Princess Bride is one of the greatest movies from the '80s. Interestingly, the book's author William Goldman was the person who fought hardest to get the movie made, and his presence may be an explanation for the film's ability to realize the novel so brilliantly.

Quiverjones garnered an interesting reaction from Reddit when they suggested it as a film that surpassed the book it was based on, leading many to celebrate both versions of Goldman's story in equal measure. In response, solarhawks said, "this is a rare case of both a book and its film being equally brilliant."

'The Mist' (2007)

A monster horror movie armed with social commentary, The Mist used the full force of the horror genre to deliver a compelling look into the human condition. It follows residents of a small town who find shelter in a grocery store when a mysterious mist cloaking a wave of deadly monsters descends upon them, but they soon realize the threat outside may be nothing compared to the evil they must face within.

Judging it against Stephen King's novella is no easy task, but Redditors agreed that the film had one great strength over its source material . AurelianoTampa proposed the film for consideration by stating, "The book is better for most of it, but the ending in the movie knocks the socks off the book ending."

'Shrek' (2001)

It may come as a shock to many to learn that DreamWorks' satirical fairy tale classic Shrek was based on a picture book released in 1990. While the book has a somewhat similar plot line to the film, many Redditors quickly pointed out the differences between the two versions of the story.

While the responses quickly became a medley of TIL posts and parodies of Smash Mouth's "All Star," some sang the film's praises as an adaptation. AWL_cow commented, "The book was so unhinged. I loved what they did with the movie adaptation!"

'The Shawshank Redemption' (1994)

Yet another exceptional film to be based on a Stephen King story, The Shawshank Redemption overcame a disappointing box office performance to become one of the defining films of the '90s. It follows an ordinary banker who, after being found guilty of murdering his wife and her lover, befriends his fellow inmates in Shawshank State Penitentiary to make for a bizarrely hopeful and beautiful movie about friendship.

While changes were made, the film largely stays true to the source material. In response to the Redditor who initially mentioned the movie, Gunslinger666 concurred, saying, "This is my [go-to] answer. Book is excellent. Movie manages to be better."

'Forrest Gump' (1994)

Robert Zemeckis' famous 1994 film blended elements of drama, comedy, adventure, and romance to make one of the most beloved films ever made. It focuses on the fascinating and perplexing life journey of a man with a low IQ as he documents his experiences, including meeting U.S. presidents, running across America, and serving in Vietnam.

While the movie goes on wild and wacky narrative tangents, it is nothing compared to what the character in the book goes through. However, the novel lacked the film's charm, as was pointed out by excaligirltoo, who simply stated, "The book was… something."

'Who Framed Roger Rabbit' (1988)

A mesmerizing marriage of animation and live-action, Who Framed Roger Rabbit is a timeless comedy classic and one of the most iconic movies ever made. While loosely based on Gary K. Wolf's novel Who Censored Roger Rabbit , the fun fantasy film makes wholesale changes to depict a jaded but sympathetic cartoon-hating detective forced to protect a "toon" framed for murder.

As noted by Yakb0, the original novel lacked much of the film's fun, with Valiant ( Bob Hoskins' character) being a hard-nosed thug without a motive and Roger being dead for the most part. The Redditor said, "The producers of the movie took the idea of a world with toons and humans and threw away the plot. They made the right choice; the movie turned out amazing."

'Jaws' (1975)

To this day, Jaws remains an iconic horror film that cemented Steven Spielberg as one of the greatest filmmakers of all time and has had audiences fearing the beach for the better part of 50 years. The film is so impressionable and renowned that it has completely overshadowed the novel of the same name that it was based upon.

While many Redditors maintained that the book was good, the community largely agreed that Spielberg's changes made for a better story. The user annieknowsall was the initial commenter, receiving over 2,000 upvotes for saying, "I think Spielberg was right to eliminate some of the subplots and to buff the characters up to be more likable/relatable. Also, the end of the book kinda sucked."

'The Godfather' (1972)

When it comes to Hollywood brilliance, there is hardly a film from any genre that can rival the reputation and prestige of The Godfather . Based on Mario Puzo's crime novel of the same name, the film tracks the transition of power in a New York crime family from an aging patriarch to his smart though reluctant son.

The film won three Academy Awards and has become one of the most well-known movies ever, surpassing Puzo's best-selling novel in the eyes of many. amerikanische_Frosch commented, "The book was obviously a best seller but it had some really – REALLY – cringey side plots… which Coppola wisely dropped from the film."

KEEP READING: The 10 Authors Who Have the Most Book-to-Movie Adaptations